A user, Donald_Swofford, reported that newly created categories display an unedited ‘About’ topic to all users, including guests, despite guidance suggesting it should remain hidden until edited. After clarification from codinghorror and HAWK, it became clear this behavior is intentional — the ‘About’ topic is visible within the category itself (not the categories page) and is meant to be editable by anyone for meta-discussion. Donald_Swofford initially expected it to be staff-only, similar to admin guides, but accepted the explanation after realizing the distinction. He later suggested hiding unedited ‘About’ topics from public view to avoid signaling lack of stewardship [13]. Another user, tophee, noted a related issue: unedited ‘About’ topics appear as unread on ‘Latest’ and ‘New’ pages, which may confuse users. codinghorror confirmed the outdated guidance has since been removed. The thread concludes with consensus that while the behavior is by design, UX improvements — such as hiding unedited topics or excluding them from unread counts — may be worth considering as future enhancements.
Whenever I create a new category the topic that says:
(Replace this first paragraph with a brief description of your new category. This guidance will appear in the category selection area, so try to keep it below 200 characters. Until you edit this description or create topics, this category won’t appear on the categories page. )
My understanding is that is supposed to be a hidden topic that only the admin or mods can see? Am I wrong in that assumption? All my visitors can see "Replace this first paragraph.."which should be private to me and staff which seems like undesired behavior and a bug?
I’m sorry its slowly sinking in. I didnt understand it was specific to that one view I thought it meant categories page as in the idea not the view. Shouldn’t that also just be hidden in general from anyone that doesn’t have the ability to edit that topic i.e. staff. So I guess I’m wondering if this should be a feature request?
Ok, I give. I was just hoping it would be more like the READ ME FIRST: Admin Quick Start Guide where it’s for my eyes only in case I forget so i dont look silly.
So even though everything seems to behave as intended, here is a related phenomenon that drove me nuts today: My “Latest” page was showing one unread topic even though there was no unread topic in sight on the entire page. Only when I saw that also the “New” page had one unread message (it wasn’t evident at first, because I was on mobile) and that page finally revealed to me what that one unread topic was: it was the “About this category” topic of a newly created category that I had not yet edited.
So it would probably be more consistent if those unedited “About this category” topics wouldn’t only be hidden from “latest” but also not count against the unread count. Or - well, I’m actually not quite sure what exactly is going on.
I don’t see what benefit they provide to anyone that is not staff etc. A friendly reminder is helpful but advertising lack of stewardship to visitors doesn’t seem helpful.