The discussion revolves around the behavior of BBCode for block-level italic and bold text. jack2 highlights that adding an empty line within [i] tags causes the BBCode to fail, questioning if this is intended. codinghorror suggests that [i] is not meant for multi-line use, while Remah notes that BBCode is typically single-line and recommends using <br /> for multi-line formatting. jack2 confirms that also works. sam clarifies that italic and bold BBCode are not designed for multi-line use, as they are inline elements in HTML, though open to changes if there’s demand. riking argues against encouraging such formatting, viewing it as low-effort and potentially annoying.
Yeah italic bbcode block is not implemented as a multiline. This is current intended behavior. Same goes for bold. The reason I did this is that <i> and <b> also are treated as inline vs block level tags in html.
I am open to expanding this use case if there are enough requests for it, but as it stands it is behaving as designed.
Writing multiple paragraphs of italic / bold text without putting in the effort to put the formatting tag on every paragraph is one of the kinds of low effort-to-annoyance-ratio forum posts that I don’t think should be encouraged.