The discussion revolves around the allow uploaded avatars by trust level feature in Discourse, where users are experiencing unexpected behavior. tmomas notes that TL0 users are able to upload avatars despite the setting restricting this to TL1 and above. JammyDodger replicates the issue and suggests that social sign-ups or SSO might be involved, but tmomas confirms the issue persists even without such integrations. A key observation is that unverified users are also seen with custom avatars. JammyDodger identifies the automatically download gravatars setting as a likely cause, explaining that it can assign Gravatars to unverified users, potentially misleading them into appearing as having uploaded avatars.
I’ve just had a little go on my test site (allow uploaded avatars: TL1, with a TL0 Test_User) and I get this ‘reduced options’ version of the screen when I try and change my avatar:
Do you have any social sign-ups, or SSO on your site? Maybe they could be auto-filling the profile picture on sign-up? (I’m speculating, as I don’t have much experience with those )
Just tried myself with a testuser which switched from TL1 → TL0 → TL1: Yes, I observe the same as you, TL0 can not upload own avatar picture, but TL1 can.
only github, but I see TL0 users with and without github under “Associated accounts” with own avatar pictures, therefore thinking it is not related to the github login.
Additional observation: I even see new users with unverified email (and with no “Associated accounts” entry) having their own avatar pictures.
If a user hasn’t even verified his emailadress, how can he have his own avatar picture?