Anonymous posting ONLY for original topic (not replies)

AI-generated summary

In a support discussion titled ‘Anonymous posting ONLY for original topic (not replies),’ slpollack asks if Discourse can allow anonymous posting only for the original topic author, while requiring replies to be non-anonymous — to encourage honest, sensitive questions while preserving accountability in responses. simon notes no built-in feature exists but suggests a plugin-based solution using group permissions to restrict anonymous users to topic creation only. He also observes users may naturally adopt anonymous mode for sensitive questions without system changes, since responders would likely prefer to answer under their real identity. Mittineague questions how ‘foolproof’ the anonymity needs to be, noting CSS or JavaScript can hide information from casual users, but determined users could still recover it — true removal would require server-side (Ruby) changes. slpollack appreciates the CSS workaround but expresses concern about creating a false sense of true anonymity. The thread reflects a practical desire to balance psychological safety for questioners with transparency and credibility in replies, within Discourse’s current architecture.

Hi all,

Is it possible to enable anonymous posting ONLY for the original poster, but NOT for replies?

The intention here is to allow someone to more comfortably post a sensitive topic or “stupid question” without worry, but to have non-anonymous replies to the OP that retain the context around who’s answering (e.g., is this person’s answer reputable based on their experience, etc.).

Is this particular nuance of anonymous posting possible?

I like the idea, but there is nothing built into Discourse that would force users to only use anonymous mode for creating topics. A plugin that added anonymous users to a group that had “Create / Reply / See” permissions on a category that only allowed regular users to “Reply / See” the category would probably solve the problem.

It seems likely to me that users could just adopt the behaviour of entering anonymous mode to ask “stupid questions” without making any changes to Discourse. If users know the answer to the question, they will probably want to post the answer from their non-anonymous account.

How “foolproof” does it need to be? I imagine most of the information could be easily hidden with some CSS display: none, but the information could be found if one was determined to see it.

JavaScript could take the information out of the DOM, but again, the information could be found if one was determined to see it.

AFAIK, the only way to entirely remove it from the output HTML, RSS, JSON, email, (other?) would require some Ruby but maybe JavaScript alone would be enough?

Thanks. The CSS trick is an interesting workaround, though I’d still be a bit queasy about providing the false expectation of true anonymity.