Badge Discussion: Like Ratios + Spending Likes

Note the additional multipliers per trust level.

2 „Gefällt mir“

Thanks @DeanMarkTaylor!

Now that I have some numbers to work with…

@pfaffman pointed out that long-term members don’t need this kind of encouragement. I would disagree here. I feel it is just as important to keep your long term users engaged, happy, and participating as it is to train new users to use likes.

For new user through TL1, they need 50 likes in a day to receive this badge. That limit isn’t too high, but I feel that one is unlikely to hit it unless they really like giving likes, or a site is very, very active. I would assume that this like limit was was tweaked based on feedback back when it was first instituted, and thus is at a level where the majority of new users don’t hit it. Once a user is around for at least 15 days and has regular participation on the site, their limit goes up to 75. Be really, really active and hit 50 days and your limit goes up to 100 (assuming the multipliers are not cumulative). Get the manual promotion to TL4 and the limit is now 150.

150 is a lot of likes. At Stonehearth we average 100 posts a day. So while a new user would only need to like ~1/2 of the posts in a day to hit their limit, a long-term user would need to like every new post, plus half of the posts from the previous day. Unlike some badges with high numbers required to gain (like the Nice share/post/topic badge), this badge requires a single user to click like x times, and they have only 24 hours to do so. The other like related badges have no time limit.

td;dr: I am concerned about the difficulty for long-term users to achieve this badge, and it seems to be the only badge create thus far that is affected by a user’s trust level (although somewhat indirectly).

Agreed, on the team call today we decided to make the likes cast per day badge hard code to 50 rather than keying on the rate limit being hit.

4 „Gefällt mir“

Thanks for the clarification @codinghorror! Will the badge description be changed at all to cover this, or will this be “transparently” occurring in the background?

I might disagree with you here…

We’ve had a surge of like spam once the badges were found out. Granted, we are only one forum.

3 „Gefällt mir“

I think it may be time for a few new categories on the Badges page… “Community” is getting pretty dang big.

6 „Gefällt mir“

Feel free to propose a new category there

Here’s my first pass at reallocating the badges to groups:

First Flag: Community → Getting Started
Editor: Community → Getting Started
Welcome: Community → Likes
Appreciated, Out of Love, Thank You, Gives Back, My Cup Runneth Over, Respected, Admired, Crazy in Love, Empathetic: Community → Likes
Nice, Good, Great Share: Community → Promotion
Popular, Hot, Famous Link: Community → Posting
Promoter, Campaigner, Champion: Community → Promotion
Anniversary: Getting Started i suppose?

4 „Gefällt mir“

Ich habe versucht, @riking’s Beitrag zu befolgen, hatte dabei aber Schwierigkeiten, daher habe ich ihn wie auf der Badges-Seite aufgeteilt. Hier ist das Ergebnis:

##Erste Schritte
Autobiograf – Bronze
Erster Like – Bronze
Erster Link – Bronze
Erstes Zitat – Bronze
Erste Weitergabe – Bronze
Erste Flagge – Bronze
Richtlinien gelesen – Bronze
Leser – Bronze
Redakteur – Bronze

##Community-Aufbau
1-Jahres-Jubiläum – Silber
Technischer Support – Silber
Schriftführer – Gold

##Beiträge
Beliebter Link – Bronze
Netter Beitrag – Bronze
Nettes Thema – Bronze
Hotter Link – Silber
Guter Beitrag – Silber
Gutes Thema – Silber
Berühmter Link – Gold
Großartiger Beitrag – Gold
Großartiges Thema – Gold

##Vertrauensstufe
Grundlegend – Bronze
Mitglied – Bronze
Regelmäßig – Silber
Anführer – Gold

##Testen
Bug-Melder – Bronze
Tester – Silber
Senior-Tester – Silber

##Entwicklung
Mitwirkender – Bronze
Großartiger Mitwirkender – Silber
Plugin-Autor – Silber
Hervorragender Mitwirkender – Gold

##Likes
Willkommen – Bronze
Geschätzt – Bronze
Aus Liebe – Bronze
Danke – Bronze
Respektiert – Silber
Mein Becher läuft über – Silber
Gibt zurück – Silber
Bewundert – Gold
Verrückt nach Liebe – Gold
Einfühlsam – Gold

##Beförderung
Promoter – Bronze
Nette Weitergabe – Bronze
Kämpfer – Silber
Gute Weitergabe – Silber
Champion – Gold
Großartige Weitergabe – Gold

3 „Gefällt mir“

I wikified the above post if anyone wants to modify it further. I will say I am questioning why Welcome is in a separate category from First Like, seeing as the new like related badges are for both receiving and giving likes.

2 „Gefällt mir“

Note that these are custom badges on Meta only.

2 „Gefällt mir“

As are the testing and contributing categories:

1 „Gefällt mir“

A quick question: Do moderators have unlimited :heart:s?

I’m a moderator and trust level 4 on forum.gethopscotch.com, and I’ve liked over 1,500 posts in that forum and still haven’t run out of likes. If this is the case, are some badges unreachable?

1 „Gefällt mir“

There are admin settings that give TL2/TL3/TL4 additional likes per day by a specified factor. It’s not unlimited, but if that factor was really high it’s conceivable that you wouldn’t reach it.

e.g. for TL4:

tl4 additional likes per day multiplier is the name of the setting.

2 „Gefällt mir“

@kk091: Did you like over 1,500 likes in 24 hours, or in total? The like limit is per 24 hours. Also, for the purpose of these badges, the “exceeding like limit” badge is coded to the base like limit, and is not affected by the TL2/3/4 multiplier - otherwise the badge would be “biased” against higher TL users.

3 „Gefällt mir“

I am on the same forum as her and I believe I can answer this.

She liked well over 1,500 posts. I should know, I was one of the people she “spam liked”! :scream::grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

Anyway, it was all today.

As for the other portion of your post, that’s really interesting! Thanks for sharing!

3 „Gefällt mir“

I liked over 1,500 in around than five hours, which I believe is less than a day :joy:.

And what is normally the base like limit?

1 „Gefällt mir“

50…

…with a TL4 multiplier of 3 you get 150. Seems you gained a zero somehow, unless staff are exempt?

1 „Gefällt mir“

They are :dealwithit:

3 „Gefällt mir“

So if they are, it’s impossible to reach some of the badges, correct?

Is there anyway to change this?