Nieuwe onderwerpen inline vertakken

AI-generated summary

In a discussion about improving topic management in Discourse, Jack_Ukleja proposed a feature to create new topics inline during conversations, preserving context by linking back to the parent topic. He noted that tangents are valuable and should be preserved, not suppressed, especially in groups focused on resolving disagreements. renato and Falco clarified that Discourse already supports this via “Reply as Linked Topic” and admin branching tools, both of which auto-link related topics. Jack_Ukleja expressed delight upon discovering the feature, admitting he hadn’t found it via search or UI exploration. rishabh reassured him that it’s a power-user feature and shared that Discourse recently promoted it on Twitter to increase awareness link. The thread highlights a useful but under-discovered capability that aligns with Jack’s vision for structured, branching discussions.

I’m aware I’m touching upon the dreaded “threaded conversation” topic here, but I experience a specific problem in one of my discussion groups that I’m wondering if a new feature may help resolve.

Any given debate topic tends to quickly go off the rails (both in person and online). Humans just can’t help but go off on tangents. This is well known, and original forum designers created visually threaded topics for the ostensible purpose of modelling this.

My discussion group is specifically aimed at resolving disagreements, whether that be a compromise, agreement or even disagreement (agree to disagree).

The thing is the tangents are in and or themselves, often fascinating topics, and not subjects we want to shut down. We likely will want to discuss and resolve those too, just maybe at a later time, or even concurrently. Given the purpose of the group, we need to tools that help to both keep the original topic at the forefront (e.g. explicit question we are trying to resolve - a “topic” in Discourse) as well as the ability to spawn off different questions.

I’m dreaming of a system where one can create a new topic inline during a discussion, which is automatically linked back to it’s parent topic, for example by highlighting some text and clicking “Create Topic about this”.

Thoughts?

2 likes

I may have misunderstood, but I think you can use Quote + Reply as Linked Topic:

Quote

Reply as Linked Topic

4 likes

At any time a poster can reply as a new topic:

And admins must branch out off-topic to a new topic using the wrench tool.

Both options will create cross-links between topics.

2 likes

I weeping. That is beautiful, thanks. I will give it a go.

P.S. I did google to see if Discourse had this feature but nothing came up, nor could I see it in the UI but I clearly needed to dig a bit deeper!

5 likes

No worries, it is a power-user feature that needs to be discovered but we just shared it on Twitter to let more users know!

2 likes