电子邮件通知设置的措辞令人困惑

In the " Add more granular user option levels for email notifications" feature that was added in 2.3.0 beta 6, the “Send me email notifications even when I am active on the site” setting was removed in favor of separate “always / only when away / never settings” for messages and for other notifications. (email_messages_level and email_level).

This is a great improvement. However, the accompanying text “Send me an email when someone quotes me, replies to my post, mentions my @username, or invites me to a topic” does not cover all emails, especially those that are sent by the watched/tracked settings in Preferences - Notifications - Categories, while these are being covered by that setting.

(Actually it seems like this was always the case, but it got more confusing now since the explicit ‘always send everything’ setting was removed).

Maybe this could be worded in more broad terms (for instance: “topic activity notifications”) so it would cover the category notifications as well ?

3 个赞

Maybe, propose your exact changes side by side with the original copy in a reply here?

Sure.

Current:

Send me an email when someone quotes me, replies to my post, mentions my @username, or invites me to a topic

Proposal #1:

Send me an email when I receive a notification regarding a topic I’m watching, tracking, or participating in

Alternative:

Send me an email when I receive a notification regarding topic activity

1 个赞

That seems extremely vague. As a rule I don’t like to replace specifics with vagueness. So the answer is currently no.

I do see some other unrelated opportunities for cleaning up copy here though..

I’d like to hear specifically which emails you feel are not covered here, with examples. And please use text, not screenshots, so we can all save some time..

3 个赞

The following emails are covered by the “Send me an email when someone quotes me …etc…” setting but are not included in the descriptive text for that setting:

  • emails that are sent because a notification is generated because a new post or topic is created in a category I’m watching because it appears in the list set by Preferences - Notifications - Categories - Watched
  • emails that are sent because a notification is generated because a new topic is created in a category I’m “watching first post” for (set by Preferences - Notifications - Categories - Watching first Post)
  • emails that are sent because a notification is generated because a new post is created in a topic I’m watching because I set it to ‘watching’ on the bottom of the topic
2 个赞

Could be like the following:

Send me an email when someone quotes me, replies to my post, mentions my @username , or invites me to a topic, and also regarding categories and topics I’m watching.

Maybe the text is a bit too long, but I think it is clear about what it does.

3 个赞

我正试图撰写一份关于通知和电子邮件通知机制的总结,但觉得有些困难。不过,这个帖子,尤其是这段措辞,给了我很大帮助。

关于这一点,我目前的理解是,对于仅仅是被“追踪”的内容,不会发送电子邮件(您随后提供的有帮助的总结也反映了这一点)。

1 个赞

这是我目前整理的内容。它紧接在关于最新页面、通知页面和数字计数的段落之后。

您可以将以下级别应用于分类、标签或主题:

  • 关注 — 通知:新主题和回复。计数:新主题和回复。
  • 追踪 — 通知:仅当有人回复您时。计数:新主题和回复。
  • 关注首帖(仅限分类) — 通知:分类中的新主题,但不包括回复。计数:新主题。
  • 正常 — 通知:仅当有人回复您时。计数:无。
  • 静音 — 通知:无。计数:无。

以及

默认情况下,如果您离开论坛,系统将向您发送任何您处于 关注关注首帖 状态的通知邮件。

在我润色措辞之前,能否请您检查一下准确性?@RGJ

谢谢。

当我写下上述内容时,我以为“通知级别”中提到的“计数”是指右上角的数字。

现在我意识到,那个数字仅仅是通知的数量。否则就不合逻辑了。

这个“计数”必须是主题列表中出现在主题名称右侧的某个按主题统计的数字——很可能是蓝色圆圈中显示的“未读”数量。

如果我发现这也是错的,我会更新这一点!

这曾让我困惑了一会儿。邮件偏好设置文本中完全缺失“关注”相关选项,让我怀疑关注通知是否真的会发送邮件。

目前显示的是:
“当有人引用我、回复我的帖子、@提及我的用户名,或邀请我参与某个话题时,发送邮件通知我”

据我所见,应该改为:
“当有人引用我、回复我的帖子、@提及我的用户名、邀请我参与某个话题、回复我关注的话题,或在我关注的分类或标签下发起新话题时,发送邮件通知我”

或许可以简化为:
“当有人引用我、回复我、提及我、邀请我、回复我关注的话题,或在我关注的话题下发起新话题时,发送邮件通知我”

我在设置一个 Discourse 实例以替代部分邮件列表时,也曾对此感到困惑。我不希望默认行为像邮件列表那样,因此需要为那些希望保持邮件列表体验的用户提供说明(即关注特定类别,而不是接收所有内容)。

上述相关偏好设置的标题是:

当有人给我发消息时发送邮件

因此,我在我们的实例上自定义了文本,将以下内容:

当有人引用我、回复我的帖子、@提及我的用户名或邀请我参与话题时发送邮件

改为:

当我收到任何其他通知时发送邮件

我不完全确定这是否是最佳措辞,但我认为它与相关文本配合得很好,例如在选择关注某个类别时:

你将自动关注该类别下的所有话题。你将收到每个话题中每篇新帖子的通知,并且会显示新回复的数量。

1 个赞

我确实深受此问题困扰。我有很多用户习惯于邮件列表,我正在努力温和且务实地引导他们适应新方式。

Jeff,我理解这种顾虑,但完全忽略一个重要的具体情境似乎也不妥。例如:

为我发送所有通知的电子邮件,包括已关注 和已追踪 的话题,以及当有人引用我、回复我的帖子、@提及我的用户名或邀请我加入某个话题时

这确实涵盖了所有通知,对吗?

我认为你不会收到已追踪主题的电子邮件。

啊,是的,正如我所说的,我觉得这很令人困惑。:slight_smile: 我会编辑上面的内容。

1 个赞

默认措辞确实存在不足。

所以,我将为我的网站执行此操作:


js.user.email_messages_level,默认为“当有人给我发消息时给我发电子邮件”,将变为:

当我收到私人消息时给我发电子邮件

这与用于启用/禁用其他成员私人消息的偏好设置中使用的“私人消息”一词相匹配。


js.user.email_level.title,默认为“当有人引用我、回复我的帖子、提及我的@用户名或邀请我加入主题时给我发电子邮件”,将变为:

收到所有通知时给我发电子邮件。这包括在关注的主题、类别和标签中的帖子;以及当有人引用我、回复我的帖子或提及我的@用户名时。

(我们没有启用邀请功能,所以我将其省略了。)


2 个赞

您可以去掉“所有”并说“…用于通知,包括…”

或者甚至可以识别所有这些并去掉“包括”或“包括”之类的词。

是的,这很有道理,尤其是考虑到您可以选择的选项是“始终”、“仅在离开时”和“从不”。

我没有信心能识别所有这些。:slight_smile:

等待 @JammyDodger 发布他的论文

2 个赞

此文本已更新,现在显示:

当我被引用、回复、我的@用户名被提及,或者在我关注的类别、标签或主题中有新活动时,请给我发邮件。

3 个赞