Disable topic edit notifications

Hey all - is there anyway to disable the notifications that users see if their topic was edited, particularly if it was edited by an admin?

I regularly edit topics, spelling, etc. And Discourse notifying a user of that is… awkward. Anyway to disable this?

5 个赞

Not that I know of, no. It’s an unusual request.

Aha, I found another as fastidious as me! I would like to see a toggle for this as well.

4 个赞

For the record, whenever you’ve edited my posts here, I’ve always thought “hmm… what did I do wrong? Why did he edit my post?” :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

And what made me ask this is someone on my site asked why I edited it. It’s just awkward and if it could be easily hidden that would be :ok_hand:

3 个赞

I think a “better” solution here would be to force an edit reason and then alert with that.

So, instead of:

edit glyph: topic title

It would be:

edit glyph: Jeff: fix typo, title link

Downside is that we would have to cull lengths to something sane.

3 个赞

I do not feel this is a better solution.

I have a private business forum and often edit clients’ posts so that things like Onebox work properly (youtube links that aren’t on a clear line etc).

The idea of the forum is to be an accurate record of business discussions and requests, so sometimes clients wonder why I’d be editing their posts.

I’d love this as a feature/option.

8 个赞

I’m also looking for this feature. I had to manually fix hundreds of posts after import (cosmetic edits due to formatting) but didn’t realize it was sending notifications to the users. It was terribly embarrassing, because it sends weird signals when it looks like someone else has edited your content, even if it was actually just formatting. (Revisions are not publicly visible for other reasons.)

The only way I’ve found to get around it at the moment is to SSH into the server and do it through the Rails console.I’ve also had to disable users’ ability to add tags, because it creates more work to have to SSH into the server to change/remove them. Adding new tags to posts is also awkward due to the notifications, so I’m switching to SSH for that too.

3 个赞

Would be really nice to have this feature. I also edit topics and don‘t want to be seen as the guy with ocd who edits the tiny spelling mistakes people make :smile:

1 个赞

是否有针对此问题的解决方案?这对论坛版主来说非常有意义。有人告诉我,我的编辑会给他们带来大量的通知。

1 个赞

您好 @Valcoholics
您进行什么样的编辑会使您的用户收到“大量的”通知?

您好,

我们也在寻找此选项。

我们已从一个内部系统迁移到另一个内部系统,因此现在需要更新旧主题的链接。
我们正在生成电子邮件通知,因为更新主题上的超链接被视为一次编辑。

如果能有一个禁用主题编辑通知的设置就太好了。

谢谢。

这没什么不寻常的。

用户应该能够根据自己的意愿禁用任何和所有通知,例如,编辑原始帖子不应导致“顶”等。

我刚在这里尝试了一下,快速编辑了一个成员帖子的错别字,我看到他们收到了通知。

我个人倾向于同意 OP 的观点。在某些情况下,版主可能会觉得压制编辑通知的发送是合理的。但我也能理解,如果一个不怀好意的版主开始编辑其他人的帖子,那可能会带来麻烦。

我在我参与的几个网站上(但在元论坛上不那么频繁)经常这样做,通过选择文本并进行快速编辑来修正错别字。如果我知道发帖的成员每次我这样做都会收到通知,我可能会少做一些!:grimacing:

这也有意思,作为一种让成员知道他们帖子被编辑的_原因_的方法,以避免他们觉得他们做错了什么。不过,这将使快速编辑变得不可能。

现在我们生活在人工智能翻译的时代,我正在修复很多拼写错误和人工智能难以处理的复杂结构。希望我没有冒犯任何人,但我想这种情况可能和苏格兰语论坛一样(意味着一个词有无数种拼写方式)。

通知有点困扰用户,因为他们觉得我在修复无意义的拼写错误——我确实是这样做的。好吧,当我意识到据我所知我没有任何方法可以强制重新翻译时,我就停止了。但我的观点是,从我的角度来看,不应该有通知——除非文本的某个百分比或字符数量发生了变化。

我认为困境依然存在,一些站点需要通知,而另一些则不需要。即使是修正一个拼写错误,也可能在之后被注意到,帖子的作者会担心他们的文字被更改。

我想快速编辑弹出窗口可以像编辑器一样添加一个“编辑原因”输入框。那会很好!按钮右侧有空间。并且可以有一个管理员设置,在编辑时要求提供原因。并非所有站点都想要它,但有些站点可能会欣赏它。

1 个赞

这确实存在……但有点不直观,而且我并不总是记得。

当你编辑帖子时,在你的用户图片上方的顶部有一个信息按钮。点击添加原因,如果编辑历史是公开的,那么任何人都可以查看更改以及该原因。

1 个赞

是的,我知道在编辑帖子时存在这种情况。但说的是快速编辑……当你只选择一些文本,然后在光标旁边弹出的菜单中选择“编辑”。这会带你到上面共享的编辑模式。

这是……一个东西?有插件还是没有插件?

这是 Discourse 的一个核心功能。您可以在此处试用。您在您的网站上看不到它吗?

1 个赞