The discussion is about Level1 users being able to pin/unpin topics. Jaskaran noticed that users with Level1 can pin/unpin topics, despite the Trust Level Permissions Reference stating that only TL4, moderator, and admin should have this permission.
Moin clarified that Level1 users can unpin topics for themselves, but not for others. Jaskaran asked if disabling the default topics automatic unpin option would hide the pinned button for Level1-3 users. Moin questioned the problem being solved by preventing users from unpinning topics, and HeadShot wanted to know how to restrict pin/unpin access based on trust levels.
Moin explained that users do not automatically reach trust level 4 and that promoting users to this level implies they are trustworthy. Users with Level1 can only unpin and re-pin topics for their personal view, and cannot affect how the topic appears for other users.
That menu should be only visible for TL4 users and staff.
But as the second line says, when a topic is pinned, every user can unpin it for themselves using the dropdown at the bottom of the topic or by clicking the pin icon next to the title. They can also configure to unpin topics automatically after reading them, which is enabled by default if you didn’t change the default for your community (default topics automatic unpin)
what if we disable default topics automatic unpin option . can it hide pinned button for leve1-3 users. I am understand this Users cannot pin new topics, but they can unpin a topic that was pinned by an admin. Discourse allows this because it lets users customize their experience by choosing not to see a pinned topic at the top of their view. This personal unpinning doesn’t affect how the topic appears for other users. am I right?
Users do not reach trust level 4 automatically. As long as you do not promote them to trust level 4, they can only unpin and re-pin a topic for their personal view.
Users who you choose to promote to trust level 4 should be trustworthy enough that if you ask them not to do something, like pinning topics, they won’t do that. Otherwise you will have problems with other permissions they have too.