The goal is not to force everyone to do it; the new user tutorial is something new users should opt into. I think you have a different expectation around this feature than we do, and it is a fundamental disconnect.
Are you absolutely sure the first message spotlight is working on your site, e.g. this? Can you sign up as a new user and verify?
I don’t expect most users to read the instructions, decide to go the extra mile, and bookmark that initial message to trigger to new user narrative, the same way I don’t expect every student in class to sit in the front row and earn an A+ grade in the course.
What would be concerning, and what @tgxworld and I look at, is …
if there is any particular step that people get hung up on in the narrative.
if people can’t even open their first message containing the essential information that discobot provides:
Remember, the new user narrative is completely optional and something that new users have the choice of completely ignoring if they want to. Maybe they’ve joined 20 discourses by now, so this tutorial is old hat to them. It is not a requirement and I would expect most users to ignore it. Heck, if they actually read just the 3 bullet points that discobot gives them, that’s a win!
Same here. Well, actually not as bad. I’ve had three out of 90 new users reply to the bot, one of them completed the entire tutorial , one did a couple of steps and one reacted to one of the three bullet points but probably didn’t see that there was a tutorial waiting.
Of course users are entirely free to decide whether they want to do the tutorial or not. But what we don’t quite know at the moment is whether they are even aware of that choice. My feeling is that most are not and that there is room for making them more aware of it.
As a start, I have modified the first bullet point to mention the purpose of the bot (rather than “I’m just a robot” it now says something like “I’m a robot that can help you learn how to use this forum”). If that doesn’t increase the ratio of people who at least reply once, I might try to move the bookmark task into the first bullet point.
If the team is open for exploring alternative ways of starting the tutorial, my suggestion would be to make the first message extremely short. Something like “Hi, I’m a robot who can show you how to use this fodum. Would you like me to show you something?” If that doesn’t raise people’s curiosity then I’d give up and accept that most people are simply not interested.
The three bullet points would then come up in the second message and if the user doesn’t reply to the first one, there would be a special timeout message delivering the three bullet points.
I have been following this closely from the beginning so I am pretty sure I understand your intent and am on board with it. My new users get what you call a “first message spotlight” - the functionality is working.
This is my issue - it seems to me that right at the outset people don’t know what to do with this “Greetings” message from discobot. Happy to let it play out longer but it seems the first action is too confusing if not impossible to grasp by my users…
I suspect they are TL;DR-ing the message and not reading to the bottom even though it is just three bullets and a last sentence. It is at the bottom for a reason though.
Thanks, Jeff! you’re probably right. and it’s not the end of the world for them to ignore it.
I just did another test and noticed one discrepancy - on my site, as a new user I don’t need to select ... to see the bookmark option on the post menu. It’s just right there. So that might be confusing some folks as well. See screenshot.
I try very hard to avoid customizing my discourse at all, and prefer to trust the judgment discourse team. If my feedback is not accepted then there’s usually a good reason for that.
However, in the interests of science I have changed the text to remove the reference to ... and the present so we’ll see what happens with that. It now reads:
If you’d like to learn more, select below to bookmark this private message.
thanks Christoph! This is the language I used, which flows a bit better:
I can show you some cool features of this forum right now. Are you ready? Let’s start by bookmarking this private message: just select below and then hit .
Someone call me out as a dumbo, but where do I find this if I’m NOT a new user? Any way to force this upon everyone now that it exists? Why exclude all existing users from ever attaining the certified/licensed badges? Or am I missing something? How and where do I talk to this bot?
I was using a new Discourse site and wanted to get the badges for the tutorials. I had no idea how to start them as I ignored the welcome message. Saw it but didn’t read it.
Had to come back here to figure it out.
Actually I still can’t figure it out once going back to that new site.
The site I was using didn’t have the bot sending out PM’s to new users AFAICT. But there was a regular post “from the bot” in the site’s “introduce yourself” topic, telling folks how to trigger the tutorial via a PM to the bot with the special command. I don’t admin that site so can’t say how exactly it’s configured or how the instructional post was created.
I’m sure it won’t be popular for everyone, but what about a “Tutorial” link in the hamburger menu that would pre-populate a message to the bot with the start tutorial command, and also telling people to send the PM to start the tutorial? (Random brainstorming.)
If I’m correctly assuming that you’re referring to this post, I wrote the post as my user and then changed ownership to the bot. Truly new users do get the bot tutorial but because we did a mass import, most “new” users aren’t actually new but were created when they joined the original Google Group. I still wanted a way to trigger the tutorial for those who wanted and that post was the best I could come up with. Plus, it made me laugh.
I definitely would have been lost otherwise, although I suppose I was an edge case. (Imported users, but that might also apply to SSO-created users too? Not sure.)
, one did a couple of steps and one reacted to one of the three bullet points but probably didn’t see that there was a tutorial waiting.
in the future” is somewhat obscure. It does not really encourage people to actually do the bookmarking task.
below to bookmark this private message.
Are you ready? 
Let’s start by bookmarking this private message: just select 
below and then hit 
instead of 
How and where do I talk to this bot?
