The discussion revolves around the ability to create a partial view of hidden content in Discourse, specifically for membership sites. dylanb wants to allow non-logged-in users or non-members to view the first few posts in a private category but hide the rest and display a message indicating that it’s only for members. However, codinghorror expresses opposition to implementing a “paywall” feature.
dylanb suggests customizing the “Oops! That page doesn’t exist or is private” screen to indicate that the content is available for members only. Anatolia proposes a message like “You must be a member of X Group to see this page.” Paracelsus recommends using the static pages plugin to create a custom link to a preview page.
The discussion further explores the idea of creating a “clearer” 404 page that distinguishes between “it doesn’t exist” and “it’s private.” xav shares a link to a related discussion on meta.discourse.org. dylanb asks if it’s possible to add custom content to this page, such as a link to login or register.
The conversation also touches on the topic of SEO and how a partial view of hidden content could potentially be beneficial. awesomerobot notes that while it could make content more discoverable, it might not improve ranking if users are annoyed about having to register to view the full content.
Ultimately, dylanb decides to use the “advertise activity in a private category” plugin, which better suits his needs. codinghorror suggests improving the enhanced 404 page to indicate the need for membership to a group, even if the group doesn’t allow self-registration.