The user Infinite_Flight_Sims is attempting to merge two Discourse communities by restoring a backup from an older forum to a newer one, but the restore fails with the message “Restore Failed. Check Logs.” RGJ suggests the backup file may have been truncated during transfer, advising a size comparison of the original, local, and uploaded files. itsbhanusharma clarifies that restoring a backup into an existing Discourse instance is incorrect and not supported; instead, tools exist for merging two Discourse sites, referencing a guide on merging instances here. itsbhanusharma also notes that the user is likely not restoring to a fresh install, and that the old instance should ideally be updated before backup. RGJ agrees, emphasizing that restoring an older backup into a newer instance is possible and will automatically run migrations, but the reverse is not supported.
I am trying to merge to Discourse communities together. One is running on an older version so we’re trying to transfer it to a new, and updated forum. I downloaded the old forums back ups and uploaded them to the new forum, but I’m unable to restore the back up file. It says “Restore Failed. Check Logs.”
You shouldn’t be restoring another discourse instance in an already active discourse instance. That’s never going to happen that way. There are tools to merge two discourse instances together.
He’s doing it wrong. How can he restore backup from another site to an already existing site? Per my understanding he isn’t restoring to a fresh install.
Plus, the ‘old’ discourse should probably be updated before taking backup. Isn’t it?
Yes, you’re right, I totally overlooked the “trying to merge” part. Good that it didn’t work @Infinite_Flight_Sims because you would have lost your new forum!
It is not necessary to update before taking a backup: you can restore a backup of an older discourse version into a newer instance. After restoring, all necessary migrations are run automatically.
The other way around doesn’t work.