Sort display of topics Alphabetically

Currently the list of topics can be sorted by replies, views and activity.
What about sorting by title?

Example: Here are some user guides I have created for users, I used a nomenclature for the titles. It would he helpful if the users could sort on title.

9 个赞

I’d like that feature, too. In my case, it is for a category with topics that I’d like sorted by date as each topic has a video recording of a council meeting and it would easiest to digest them in chronological order in terms of finding meetings and having a sense of what is going on in the town.

I found a work around if anyone else reads this thread looking for how they can sort their topics in a category in chronological order of some sort. See this thread:

https://meta.discourse.org/t/is-it-possible-to-change-the-creation-date-of-topics-as-admin-so-can-order-topics-chronologically/81709

5 个赞

Just wanted to cross reference a post of a user asking for support as they had a difficult time finding a meeting thread in a category. If sorting be alphanumeric was available, this would not be an issue for us.

Here is the category in question:

https://discuss.jordanbpeterson.community/c/meetings

Hi,

The ability to sort a topic list alphabetically by title would also be helpful for when Discourse is deployed as an intranet.

For instance, in MacOS, Windows, Dropbox, Google Drive, etc. “sort by name” is a default or common way to organize files. When Discourse is being used for a staff directory, to provide easy access to policy documents, to provide notes from a regular meeting, and for other common use cases in an intranet, ‘sort by name’ would be a natural and preferred way to organize content within a Category.

1 个赞

I’d use this to list topics tagged #recommendations.

Currently I manually maintain an “index” topic with links in alphabetical order to individal recommendations topics, and an automated index page with alphabetical sorting by title would save me a lot of time

2 个赞

This would be amazing

1 个赞

Alphabetically sorting would also be useful for me,
I’m building a directory with the tags and i beleive it would be worth to sort the dentists per title.

I would force them to add there name first

4 个赞

I don’t see why you shouldn’t be able to sort by any column label in the list:

You can currently sort by replies, views, and activity… why not topic as well?

1 个赞

This feature was removed after it was pointed out that the alphabetical sort is nonsensical for the Latest view.

For a knowledge base, consider using the /docs view of the Knowledge Explorer plugin instead?

4 个赞

Are there any plans to ever bring back alphabetical topic sort again?

Not at the moment, I can see in the context of docs though that makes sense. Docs - Discourse Meta. Indeed docs does allow you to sort alphabetically.

2 个赞

If I’m not mistaken, Docs only allows you to sort categories and tags alpabetically. Not the topics. I’d love to have this so that I can present the docs in a particular, sequential order.

Edit: I was wrong. You can click the topic list headers - it wasn’t obvious because there is no arrow indicating activity sort by default.

感谢您指出这一点。有人知道使用 Docs 插件是否可以默认按字母顺序排序吗?目前需要用户手动排序。

请看我分享的关于按字母顺序排序的修改的主题。我希望他们能以某种方式正式将其集成到 Docs 中 修改 Discourse Docs 以仅允许按标题排序 - dev - Discourse Meta

1 个赞

非常感谢!我真的很欣赏您的方法,我一定会试试的!我也同意,字母排序是一个很棒的功能,我们很多人都非常需要。再次感谢!

1 个赞

感谢您让这个帖子保持活跃。我知道大家对于字母排序 NOT 成为一个选项有很多强烈的情绪,并且提出了许多用例,但都被对标签和其他排序方式的辩护所回应。

我很希望有人能为我提出一个处理以下用例的方法:

我有 25 个主题,每个主题都包含一个供讨论的视频。

人们按正确的顺序观看视频非常重要。

所以,如果我给主题编号并进行字母排序,我们就完成了。用户可以从顶部开始,然后向下进行。他们只需要记住上次在哪里停止,下次继续。

但是

如果我使用任何现有的排序选项,它们都会被打乱。唯一可能的解决方法是创建日期,但这使得我很难以任何有用的方式编辑列表。

是我误解了我的用例,还是我被卡住了?我问了机器人,但它放弃了。

谢谢。

@codinghorror Jeff,不确定这是否引起了您的注意……

感谢您的考虑。

您能否编辑主题时间戳以创建您需要的顺序?例如,我将这些时间戳设置为相隔 1 小时(00:00、01:00、02:00),然后如果我想稍后添加“Lesson 1.1、Lesson 1.2 等”,就可以在它们之间插入多达 59 个额外主题(通过一些时间戳调整)。这对您有用吗?

(按“创建时间”排序的类别)。

不过,一旦主题有了回复,更改时间戳也会更改回复的时间戳,但如果您添加新主题,这可能不会影响任何内容。

不过我承认,这并不能替代允许类别中设置主题顺序,这可能是理想的解决方案。 :slight_smile:

1 个赞

是的,这是个变通方法,但当然,社区构建的软件解决方案的优点在于,也许我们可以避免这种情况……

谢谢 @JammyDodger

2 个赞

我们目前有一个新的 /filters 端点供登录用户使用。(完整主题 在此处

我与 @tgxworld 核实过,似乎实现 order:title 并不难,他已经添加了一个待审核和合并的补丁。

想知道这是否适合你?

3 个赞

如果管理员可以为给定主题设置此选项作为默认选项,那就能完成工作,谢谢 @nat

有什么方法可以知道它是否在工作吗?