I am considering switching my main forum http://www.glitchhopforum.com to discourse, but i am concerned about spam prevention. That board gets quite a lot of spam attempts, which have been pretty much completely decimated by using Stop Forum Spam countermeasures. In the past 3 months alone it has blocked over 10,000 spam posts. Is there anything like this being setup for discourse, or what would be a good way to go about it?
The odds of spammers having any canned solution for us is basically nil.
Even after a year, we’ll still be a small fish.
On top of those facts of life, we built Stack Exchange as our previous project, which unlike Discourse allows completely anonymous, no-login-required participation. A far tougher scenario, since anyone could just start typing in a text box right now and spam away to their heart’s content.
May I ask, how many mechanmism Discourse is running in idle mode and how we keep runing our community spam free in future? Is Askisnet also free for non-profits?
You’re doing an excelent job at this Our last community software phpBB was a magnet for spamers and we were spending recently more time with cleaning up insted of supporting our members. That was painfull.
My discourse has been online for three days (no akismet enabled) and I have some spam bot signups, but no actual spam in the forum.
A global, collaborative blacklist might also make sense. A few of those exist, can discourse check against that? At any rate, just as a trivia, the spam bots I am now seeing have funny email domains like @site.insurple.com or @old.syfyman.com
On my non-Discourse forum, StopForumSpam integration has made a huge difference at preventing human spam signups. Plus it’s free. I would strongly prefer SFS over Akismet if I were to migrate to Discourse.
I think that is fair, however it would be nice to offer hobbyists something here plus it would be a good test for the review queue changes @eviltrout is doing. SFS is doing 480 requests a second which is quite a high number.
I think we could potentially commission a plugin here for SFS.
Looking at absolute numbers of scanned posts looks like SFS is at 50,531,189,226 and Akismet is at 463,220,426,871. So SFS is 410 billion behind but 50 billion is not a terrible number.
SFS has been around for a long time, and it’s one of the top options for non-Wordpress CMSes, so I wouldn’t worry about its sustainability.
Another thing is that I kind of prefer the non-heuristic functionality of SFS. It’s all very predictable and simple for me as the admin, I can just configure the thresholds based on X number of times the IP or email or username appears in the database, and that’s it.
I’ve been getting a few new spam users per week in my Discourse forums. Since all of them happen to be in the Stop Forum Spam database, I decided to create a plugin to immediately auto silence spam users as soon as they sign up. If interested, you can find my plugin here: