Instead of automatically tagging topics, I would like the idea of suggesting tags just as similar topics are suggested, but I imagine this isn’t that cheap to have (because we would need to maintain some sort of model/corpus per tag).
What if tags would populate as you type and before posting you could add/remove tags? Would that be OK?
Would like to see option on the Category>Edit>Tags screen for:
Default tags for this category
below the current options:
This would also help for topics posted via mobile since adding tags is not supported.
My use case is adding an “events” tag so that topics from different event subcategories across the site can get aggregated to one calendar.
A bayesian algorithm would work well here.
To seed it, feed in all the current tagged posts, and let it learn which words in the content of a post correspond (probabilistically) to which tags.
Merged in from a duplicate topic.
Great WP plugin and seems it would be a great Discourse plugin as well if built to the same logic as this one.
Yuss! I was hoping for something like this recently when I built a ‘homepage’ that relies on tagging to group content.
See how Wikibots are working at Wikipedia, it is a good reference model… Other important criteria to policy and implementation:
to be an assisted agent: never (or very rare) an automatic classification with no human confirming it. Must work “by (assisted) lot” not in a continous (by demand) way.
to be specialized: never generic, need a scope and limited (configurable/controlable) range.
to be symmetric over validation: an human can be also use the same tag, the robot (software agent) is not the only autorithy to tagging its scope. So two cenarios: 1. robot tagging and human validating/confirming (or warning to vote). 2. human tagging, and robot valiating (or warning to other human confirm).
Whith this basic polices the robot is viable in any community!
Other suggestion: when the scope is specific, or when the “easy to tag” generates “tag pollution”, the best is to use different color to the tags of the bot-scope. EXAMPLE: tagging languages in a multilingual community as https://discuss.okfn.org.
Now that we have watched words that trigger certain actions, wouldn’t it be easy to simply add “tag” as a possible action to perform upon a matched word/regex?
It’s a feature that is closer to being implemented now, yes. “Simply adding tag” isn’t quite the whole story. Each watched word needs to also specify which tag to add, for example.
That would be absolutely awesome! Especially if it’s not just words but also regular expressions. Auto-tagging based on regular expressions would bring tags in discourse to a whole new level!
Yes, and I also realize that the existing actions apply to posts while tags can only be applied to topics. So the question is: will tagging actions only be based on the first post? Or can any reply also trigger the tag? Or will it be a setting, whether it applies to both?..
Did anyone endup building this as a plugin?
@vinothkannans is currently working on something along these lines for PMs. I’m not sure how much extra work there would be to make it fit this brief – can you comment Vinoth?
You can create a plugin with the below simple code. But the difficulty level is fully depends upon your auto tagging logic/requirement.
DiscourseEvent.on(:topic_created) do |topic| guardian = Guardian.new(Discourse.system_user) DiscourseTagging.tag_topic_by_names(topic, guardian, ["bug"], append: true) if topic.title.match(/bug/) end
@syl solved this with definable auto-tagging in his Docus plugin. I suspect someone could pull that function out to create auto-tagging if he didn’t mind.
from my perspective the most obvious solution would be for a post to be auto-tagged with the tag(s) that the user is currently on (tag-page, or post). This makes it obvious visually to the user how the feature works if they need to change it, and in most cases it will probably be correct as they will be replying to something with the tags they are replying to.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but it looks like @pfaffman implemented this plugin at https://github.com/pfaffman/discourse-topic-default-tag?
I did. It just assigns a tag to every topic created in a category, but it’s a good start on something that could apply tags depending on topic content, I suppose.
+1 this would be a really useful feature or plugin, auto tagging based on watched words (each with an assigned tag) that exist in the topic (title/body).
That’s certainly possible in a plugin. You could use my plugin above as a starting place or ask in #marketplace
Can you share a link to your plugin, @pfaffman?
I want to automatically tag all topics that contain video urls (regex from a list?) in the first post with a “video” tag and display those video tag pages in each category with masonry css and thumbnails. How to achieve that?