Unlisted topics become listed via references


(Gustavo Niemeyer) #1

When an unlisted topic refers to a listed topic, the former is backlinked in the latter, thus becoming “listed”.

Ideally topics would lose old and not gain any new back references when becoming unlisted. It seems okay to have the unlisted topics referencing the listed ones, though, if they happens to be explicitly linked there.


Unlisted topics notify users if their posts are linked
Unlisted topics notify users if their posts are linked
(Jeff Atwood) #2

Do you mean… unlisted? What the heck is an “invisible” topic?


(Gustavo Niemeyer) #3

Yes, sorry. The pt_BR translation I’m using chose to use visible/invisible instead of listed/unlisted.

Updated terminology above.


(Mittineague) #4

I’m a bit confused by the use of “invisible” and “unlisted”

If what is meant is that linking to an unlisted topic in a listed topic:
> changes the unlisted topic to listed, AFAIK that should not be happening.
> makes the unlisted topic more easily found, then yes, that is true.

Perhaps there is a misunderstanding about what “unlisted” means?
It does not mean the topic is “invisible”, it means the topic can only be accessed from a direct link to it.


(Rafael dos Santos Silva) #5

I believe he is talking about this:

So if an unlisted topic links to a listed one, the unlisted can be found in the links list on the listed.


(Gustavo Niemeyer) #6

Right, in practice the unlisted is listed. :slight_smile:


(Jeff Atwood) #7

Well, you’re not supposed to post links to unlisted topics unless you want the link out there. So from my perspective, this is a feature.

Unlisted means that: not listed in the Discourse UI proper. But if you explicitly link to it in a post you yourself typed on the computer using your keyboard? all bets are off…


(Rafael dos Santos Silva) #8

It’s the reverse.

You create a post on a unlisted topic that contains a link to a listed post.

The Discourse link magic will create a back-link in the listed topic automatically.


(Jeff Atwood) #9

OMG you’re right my bad @niemeyer I wasn’t understanding this.

That’s indeed a sort of bug.

@falco can you add something to the codepath which prevents showing the backlink if the topic is unlisted?


Unlisted topics notify users if their posts are linked
(Arpit Jalan) #12

Fixed via:

Thanks for reporting this issue @niemeyer :+1:


(Jeff Atwood) #13

This topic was automatically closed after 4 days. New replies are no longer allowed.