カテゴリが非公開の場合、Nice Replyバッジがユーザーに付与されない

サポート
1

「Nice Reply」は、返信に10件以上の「いいね」がついた場合に付与される組み込みバッジです。4人のユーザーが返信で10件以上の「いいね」を獲得しているのに、そのうち1人しか「Nice Reply」バッジを持っていません。なぜでしょうか？

「Nice Reply」は「Good Reply」や「Great Reply」とともに「posting」グループに属していることは理解していますが、バッジが付与されていない3人のユーザーにはこのグループのバッジが一切付いていないため、それでは説明がつきません。

バッジは有効化されており、念のため /sidekiq/scheduler でバッジジョブを実行済みです。

デバッグを試みるため、Nice Reply バッジの SQL を Data Explorer で実行できるように適応させましたが、10件以上の「いいね」を受けた4人のユーザーは確かに検出されました：

SELECT p.user_id, p.id post_id, p.updated_at granted_at
FROM posts p
WHERE p.post_number > 1 and p.like_count > 10

2

Are they not receiving it at all? Because there is a small bug, which doesn’t let you know that you have received the badge, but you can see it if you go to Profile > Badges

3

I have had this, the date of April 2017 is given because that is when the post that received its 10th like or in your case 25 for a good reply (albeit only given yesterday or today) was originally posted.

4

Are the posts with 10 likes in public topics? The badge is only granted for public topics.

5

They are not receiving it at all, as far as I can tell. I’m looking at /u/username/badges. It’s not just a matter of an unexpected date. I think my methodology is correct because I see the badge for 1 out of 4 users.

6

Yes, it’s public. I don’t see a difference between the topic in which the one successful user posted, and the topics in which the unsuccessful three users posted.

Good to know though.

7

I’d like to try to debug this. Is there a way I could run the badge job from the console, maybe with verbose output, to see what it’s thinking?

8

Is this category “public” enough to earn the Nice Reply badge?

image

9

No, they need to have “everyone” can “See”. (and not the “Do not grant badges for posts in this category” box but I assume that isn’t your problem)