Usuários não recebem o emblema Nice Reply quando a categoria não é pública

“Resposta Legal” é uma medalha integrada para receber pelo menos 10 curtidas em uma resposta. Tenho quatro usuários que receberam mais de 10 curtidas em uma resposta, mas apenas um deles tem a medalha Resposta Legal. Por quê?

Percebo que Resposta Legal faz parte do grupo “publicação”, junto com Resposta Boa e Resposta Ótima, mas os três que estão sem a medalha não possuem nenhuma medalha desse grupo, então isso não explica.

Tenho as medalhas habilitadas e executei o trabalho de medalhas em /sidekiq/scheduler, apenas para ter certeza.

Para tentar depurar, adaptei o SQL da medalha Resposta Legal para rodar no Data Explorer, e ele realmente encontra meus quatro usuários com 10 ou mais curtidas:

SELECT p.user_id, p.id post_id, p.updated_at granted_at
FROM posts p
WHERE p.post_number > 1 and p.like_count > 10

Are they not receiving it at all? Because there is a small bug, which doesn’t let you know that you have received the badge, but you can see it if you go to Profile > Badges


I have had this, the date of April 2017 is given because that is when the post that received its 10th like or in your case 25 for a good reply (albeit only given yesterday or today) was originally posted.

Are the posts with 10 likes in public topics? The badge is only granted for public topics.

They are not receiving it at all, as far as I can tell. I’m looking at /u/username/badges. It’s not just a matter of an unexpected date. I think my methodology is correct because I see the badge for 1 out of 4 users.

Yes, it’s public. I don’t see a difference between the topic in which the one successful user posted, and the topics in which the unsuccessful three users posted.

Good to know though.

I’d like to try to debug this. Is there a way I could run the badge job from the console, maybe with verbose output, to see what it’s thinking?

Is this category “public” enough to earn the Nice Reply badge?

image

No, they need to have “everyone” can “See”. (and not the “Do not grant badges for posts in this category” box but I assume that isn’t your problem)