Users mistake top-level categories for lack of permissions

PR is up: https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/5516

4 Likes

I reviewed the PR but unfortunately it introduces another AJAX call for the “standard case” which is not acceptable.

I also question not selecting anything, if someone clicks “New Topic” on “Feature” and then it goes to the “first item” in the category list, well it will cause “different” confusion.

  • Why is it selecting “bug” when I do “new topic” in feature?

I think the correct way to go about this @Drew_Warwick is simply to allow creation of topics on “feature” and add a topic template there that warns them to select a proper feature subcategory.

1 Like

Gday,

One way to solve this might be to not show topics under the category, just subcategories. Then members would be more likely to go to the subcategories. I want that for a different reason as discussed here. :slight_smile:

https://meta.discourse.org/t/remove-topics-listed-under-sub-categories-that-are-also-in-the-sub-categrories/80901

2 Likes

Hmmm interesting. Maybe a theme component like this would help. But you lose out on being able to browse all of the parent category in one spot which may be a problem for some people.

1 Like

Looking at:

https://meta.discourse.org/t/remove-topics-listed-under-sub-categories-that-are-also-in-the-sub-categrories/80901/16?u=sam

I think this is quite a great solution for your problem here @Drew_Warwick , it very much simplifies stuff for end users.

7 Likes

Could we reuse this work here?

4 Likes