In a discussion titled ‘Why are email addresses hidden behind a “show” button in admin?’, users debate the rationale and usability of requiring an extra click to view user email addresses in the admin panel. watchmanmonitor expresses frustration, wishing all user data — including email and full name — were visible by default in admin for efficiency, especially when reviewing large batches of users. kensims notes that while they don’t mind the extra step, auditing spammy content still requires visiting public profiles. downey clarifies that the click-to-show mechanism is for auditability — viewing emails is logged. DeanMarkTaylor suggests the moderators_view_emails setting should also affect admin visibility, but watchmanmonitor reports it doesn’t work as expected, prompting DeanMarkTaylor to suspect a bug. riking cites past complaints about accidental data exposure as the reason for the design. Mittineague argues that hiding emails and IPs from moderators hampers moderation efforts. The thread concludes with watchmanmonitor proposing that the show email on profile setting be extended to the admin view to improve workflow, and links to a related feature request for editing full names in admin.
I’m vetting a new user, even though what I log is the date, IP address, username, email address, and full name, I also need to see if they put anything spammy in the website or bio, so unless all of that is going to be available on the admin page (which seems unreasonable to me), I’m going to need to visit their public profile anyway. So I personally don’t see that aspect as a big deal.
As for the extra click to see the email address (and the fact that showing an email address gets logged), it seems to me that the rationale was discussed, but I couldn’t find it in a quick search.
In that case @kensims, I’d be voting for all that to be on the admin, and forward/next buttons to go from one user to the next in the admin.
@downey if it really is about accountability.. then an option for “I don’t care if these are looked at” would be great, especially since they are just an export away.
In fact, I think Ill just start exporting more often, and doing my auditing there.. not as nice as in the admin area directly but let’s the Team get on to bigger fish..
We average probably around one new user every 3-4 days, so no biggie for me. But if you get multiple new users per day I can see how the current situation becomes much more of an issue.
I don’t think we’ve ever had that many new users even when we’ve had a big influx from The Seasteading Institute being mentioned in a popular news source.
It sounds like exporting may well be your best option.
It would make sense for it to also show in admin if it’s being shown in on the users profile to staff.
Although in a simple test toggling the option didn’t work for me in v1.4.0.beta1 +34…
… it might need a ./launcher restart app to kick in - but you would need to test that.
This always seemed like a strange setting. Why would I need to display my own email address on my own profile for my own self (and maybe admins)? It would make more sense if it were displayed publicly, but I already know my own email address.
That may hold true for Staff but IMHO the decision to not show email addresses and IPs to Moderators was a big step back for moderation effort and a big plus for making things easier for problem accounts.
Some info can be inserted via a browser extension eg.