Users are reporting that replies to report PMs are not appearing in their inbox or triggering notifications, despite being visible in sent items. Stephen first identified the issue, noting that while admins like @Hawk reply to flagged posts, these replies don’t show up in the user’s inbox or generate notifications. jomaxro confirmed the bug occurs when using the “Delete Post and Agree with flag” option, but not when using “Ignore.” maja and later maja fixed the notification issue via code changes, but Stephen and others clarified that the fix only applies to new notifications, not historical ones. Stephen and Chaboi_3000 confirmed the issue persists, with replies still missing from the inbox and no notifications sent, even after the fixes. codinghorror noted the fix was for notifications, not inbox visibility, and Stephen emphasized that the lack of inbox visibility is a separate concern. The discussion highlights a disconnect between automated replies and inbox visibility, with users expecting replies to appear in their inbox and trigger notifications.
Flagged a post ~1 day ago here on meta. Never saw a response in my inbox, so just dug through my sent items and can see that Hawk did in fact reply 19 hours ago. That reply still doesn’t show in inbox and there’s no accompanying notification.
Going to dig through inbox/sent to see if I’ve missed anything else, but there’s obviously some form of disconnect between the two at the moment.
I can confirm that no notification is generated in the following scenario:
User flags a post.
User selects the “Something Else” flag type and enters a message.
Admin uses the “Delete Post and Agree with flag” option.
I can also confirm that a notification is generated for the “ignore” option.
@zogstrip, we have a lot of flag options these days. Do you need me to test each option for handling a flag, or will this be enough to start looking through the code?
Are the auto-generated replies to reports treated differently to a PM? Not seeing the notification is one thing, but my larger concern is that my inbox doesn’t show any evidence of the automated response when the report was acted on. Had I not thought to check my sent items I wouldn’t have seen a reply at all.
Sort of . Something is strange here, as the “we agree and removed the post” auto-reply does not generate a notification or appear in the inbox, but the “thanks for letting us know” (ignore) auto-reply does generate a notification and appear in the inbox.
The notification would be nice, but realising I wasn’t seeing the reply was my primary concern. The ticket about the spammer using wiki edits ties into another post I put out a while ago, if we can’t see which wiki posts a spammer has edited we can’t necessarily easily revert their damage.
If this fix is live on Meta then it’s only partial, or doesn’t resolve responses to reports which occurred prior.
Here’s an example from two weeks ago when I filed the issue, I flagged a post and can see the flag in my sent items, I can also see that @Hawk responded to that sent item from /u/stephen/messages/sent:
Sure, I get that, it’s just not the bug I reported
Surely I should see the reply too? As-is it suggests that in certain cases a message can receive a reply, without the reply being visible in messages (unless you look at sent).
Yesterday I reported a post and I can now see from my Sent items that @HAWK responded to it, but the replied-to topic doesn’t appear in my inbox and there’s no associated notification.
I had to go to my /messages/sent to see the topic at all before I knew that Hawk had responded.