Watching PM function not triggering notifications

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around the “Watching” PM function not triggering notifications for users who are not invited or tagged in a private message. WorldIsMine notes that the setting claims to notify of new replies, but it fails to do so unless the user is tagged. dax confirms that notifications only work if the user is invited or tagged, referencing a related meta discussion. WorldIsMine suggests the “Watching” option should only appear when tagged or invited, as it currently seems misleading.

When I review a PM of two users where an admin isn’t invited/tagged, switching to “Watching” does nothing when there are new replies made to the topic. The setting says “You will be notified of every new reply in this message”, but it doesn’t. Tried multiple times, even in safe mode with everything disabled. If this option is obsolete now, why keep this setting?

I remember this worked a few versions ago without the need of being invited/tagged, so was this an intentional change?

See,
https://meta.discourse.org/t/group-mentions-and-messages/36228/26?u=dax

SO, yes, if you are not invited you can’t be notified.

Didn’t realize this was related to the @tagging I’ve mentioned in the other post you’ve linked. So I guess it would make sense to disable that option in the pull down menu and it should appear only when tagged/invited, no?