Require users to "Reply as Linked Topic"

AI-generated summary

jord8on seeks a way to allow users to ask questions about specific rules in a 73-page rule-book posted in the forum, using DiscoTOC for navigation. The goal is to prevent direct replies on the rule-book topic while still enabling users to quote and ask questions — ideally by forcing replies to be created as linked topics. maiki suggests adding clear instructions at the top of the rule-book with visual examples to guide users on quoting and replying as linked topics. They also propose allowing direct replies temporarily, then moving selected conversations into their own topics — noting that users asking rule-related questions are likely comfortable with ongoing notifications. codinghorror agrees with maiki’s suggestion and confirms that closing the topic is necessary. He also mentions the existence of an automatically delete all replies after x days setting, though it may not fit the use case. The core challenge is balancing usability with structure: enabling question-asking without cluttering the rule-book topic. The recommended approach is user education via in-topic guidance and leveraging Discourse’s linked-topic reply feature.

My question is similar to this one: Can I effectively make a topic read-only?

Use case:
I have a 73 page rule-book documents that I want to post in our forums, using the magnificent DiscoTOC Automatic Table of Contents component.

I want users to be able to highlight a rule and click the “Quote” button to ask questions about specific rules.

I suppose that we would need to CLOSE the topic, but then it looks like users can’t click the reply button.

I want them to be able to “Reply” but ONLY as a linked topic… not as a reply on the Topic with the rule book.

What are the options to provide the best UX, when members are trying to ask questions or clarifications on specific rules?

A small aside at the top of the rule-book explaining how to quote and reply as a linked topic, including small images to demonstrate.

Another idea is to allow replies, and field them there, and then select all the responses in a conversation to move into their own topic. One concern is that folks will be notified of future discussion, but on the other hand folks that ask questions about rules docs are probably the kind that don’t mind. :slight_smile:

Correct, and…

The above is excellent advice.

In addition to that, we did add an automatically delete all replies after x days setting but I’m not sure that’s what you are looking for here.