The topic creator should be able to close it

AI-generated summary

Xico26, in their first post, suggests allowing topic creators to close their own topics without needing moderator intervention, citing experience on other Discourse forums. codinghorror offers a temporary workaround: users can flag the topic for closure using the “something else” flag reason. incapaz disagrees with the proposal, arguing that preventing self-deletion (and by extension, self-closure) preserves valuable discussion for future readers. They caution that allowing topic creators to close threads could lead to abuse — for example, closing a topic immediately after marking an incorrect answer as “solved,” which would mislead future visitors. They also suggest users avoid creating topics they anticipate wanting to close later. The debate centers on balancing user autonomy with the integrity and longevity of public discussions.

(My first topic here)

Hey everyone!

I participate in some forums using Discourse (like plus.diolinux.com.br or forum.manjaro.org) and I think it would be great if the person who creates the topic is able to close it and doen’t need to ask a mod.

Thanks! :grin:

2 Likes

In the meantime, you can flag it for closure using the “something else” flag reason.

4 Likes

To be fair OP did say

however just my opinion, I wouldn’t agree with this. There is a reason users can’t delete topics themselves; to preserve discussion that can be useful to future readers. Maybe don’t make topics you believe you will want to delete in the future ?

Edit: I misread, if you mean close, then this could still be abused. This would prevent future readers from adding new info that isn’t present already and possibly someone could give a wrong answer, someone could mark that answer as the solution then instantly close it. Now future readers will come across this and take the word of the user who made the wrong answer.

4 Likes