I’ve moved this conversation to a new topic since fullscreen signup / login is not a design experiment, so it didn’t feel appropriate to keep discussing it there. We can keep the conversation going here!
@haydenjames, we’re moving everyone over to these new designs because the fullscreen pages offer a focused, clear experience through signup and login, which are critical paths into the community. I can understand that you preferred the previous designs with the modal to show the community information behind signup / login, but due to the reasons @pmusaraj shared about the burden of carrying multiple signup / login paths, we will be removing the modal login/signup screens at the end of April.
I would be happy to start exploring how we could improve the new designs to work better for you. It sounds like your biggest concern is whether your members will feel confident about where they’re going to end up after completing signup / login — is that right? What other concerns do you have with the fullscreen designs?