The discussion revolves around improving the visibility of bookmarked posts on mobile by changing the bookmark icon for non-bookmarked posts. manut suggests using an outlined bookmark icon to make it easier to distinguish between bookmarked and non-bookmarked posts, noting the current color change is insufficient. awesomerobot supports the idea and welcomes a pull request (PR), confirming the required icon (kramkoob-raf) is available. manut submits a PR, and awesomerobot acknowledges it. manut confirms the topic can be marked as done, and jordan.vidrine praises the change, noting it aligns with other UI elements like the ‘in feed’ icon.
We have users on our instance who find it difficult to tell if a post is bookmarked or not as there is only a change in color when the post is bookmarked.
We think that having an “outlined” version of the bookmark icon (which does not exist in Discourse, according to the Styleguide plugin) when the post is not bookmarked could improve the situation.
Are you interested in a PR that adds the missing icon and replace it in the button ?
Yes, I think that would be a nice improvement, a PR would be welcome.
I believe we already have the icon available — the styleguide only lists what we’ve added to our subset for use. So it might be as simple as adding it to the subset and updating the unbookmarked state with far-bookmark