New user, New topic, Minimum char alert contents!

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around the character limit alert on a Discourse site. ewanly initially pointed out a potential issue with the alert, thinking the :heart: heart icon should be a :smiling_face: smiley face. However, cpradio clarified that the heart icon is meant to encourage users to like posts instead of typing short phrases. ewanly suggested adding “instead” to the alert for better understanding. codinghorror replied that the added text wouldn’t fit within the two-line goal. mirrorstage provided alternative phrasing options for the alert, incorporating the heart icon to make the message clearer.

I was testing my Discourse site as new user.

When I’d tried to create a post with less than 20 char its gave me the following alert:

I think this (:heart:) Heart icon meant to be this (:smiling_face:) Smiley face.

I know its not a big issue but it could be confusing for new users!

Nope, it is meant to be the :heart:, as it is trying to encourage the user to use the :heart: (to like a post) instead of saying things like “I agree”, or “Yes”, or “I like”

6 „Gefällt mir“

:blush: Sorry for that!

But may be adding “instead” before the question mark could be more understandable. Since the user already in writing situation :wink:

2 „Gefällt mir“

Won’t fit in two lines, which is the goal.

Posts must be at least 20 characters
Would a :heart: make your point?

Posts must be at least 20 characters
Could a :heart: do the job?

Posts must be at least 20 characters
That short, a :heart: could do.

Posts must be at least 20 characters
Brief thought? A :heart: instead!

Posts must be at least 20 characters
Short thought: use :heart: instead?

Posts must be at least 20 characters
Instead, consider a :heart:.

11 „Gefällt mir“