Direct send email to a small group in a closed category

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

Users are discussing the need for a feature to automatically send email notifications to a small, closed group (e.g., 25+ beta testers or students) when a new topic is created in a specific category. Frank_Meeuwsen initiated the thread, noting that current Discourse options don’t support direct email pushes from new topics in closed categories. pfaffman suggests forcing users to watch the category via plugins or using PMs/@mentions, though tobiaseigen questions whether PMs reliably email all group members — a concern codinghorror dismisses for small groups. tobiaseigen later clarifies confusion with group invites. Mittineague notes a minor UX quirk with group notifications not clearing unless viewed in the group message list. Godmar_Back strongly supports the feature, especially for educational use cases like replacing Piazza, and suggests auto-watching categories with optional opt-out. Finally, JammyDodger points out that admins can set default notification preferences for categories — a partial workaround. The consensus is that while workarounds exist, a native, automated email-to-group feature for new topics in closed categories is desired and not yet available.

I searched on this forum and only found this post which is quite similar to my question. But unfortunately not an answer to work upon:

We have a growing forum for our app-users. We recently started a closed category for 25+ beta testers to communicate on new features and review new betas. One of the painpoints in driving engagement and getting feedback is the lack of email possibilities. What I would like to do is make a new topic and when I save it, Discourse immediately sends out an email to the small group. I am the only one who makes new topics right now, but even when there is someone else who makes a topic, it shouldn’t be a problem. The category is very low-volume so no danger of spam.

Is this possible with Discourse? I can’t find the proper checkboxes or preferences to do this…

Thanks
Frank

2 לייקים

You can force all the users to watch the category. Here are a couple plugins (they’d need to be customized for your site)

https://github.com/techAPJ/discourse-watch-category-rzim/

https://github.com/amical/discourse-watch-category/

Also, if it’s email you want, you can PM the group or @mention them in the post.

2 לייקים

Correct me if I’m wrong but I think if the group is a large one, only a selection of people will get the email notification.

Why do you say that? The rate limiter defaults? I think that would only prevent in very large groups.. he said this is 25 people.

I think I got this confused with inviting groups to messages. With invites, only a few people get notified by email not everyone in the group.

My understanding of how groups and PMs works is evolving. :wink:

It may be particular to SitePoint, and to be clear it does not bother me. I have noticed that with the group Notication, that even if I have already read the posts by a different entry point it doesn’t clear until I go to the group message topics list. (I dismiss nothing, though I scan often)

As for emails, I don’t know. I’ve never been gone that long to use or need them as a conduit.

2 לייקים

I would like to express strong interest in this feature also.

The plugins linked are special-cased - and exporting the user lists as suggested here is not a real-time solution (and not automated).

I strongly support the use case of being able to create categories that are “auto-watched” by users. For instance, I - like others - have been using Discourse for a class I’m teaching as a Canvas/Piazza replacement. I ask all students to read the “Announcements” category, but short of collecting their emails and creating a separate email list I have no way of pushing important announcements to them via email (something that Piazza did provide). I’d be ok if auto-subscribed users could unsubscribe themselves even.

The only currently available alternative is to ask everyone to watch this category.

לייק 1

You can set defaults for category notifications in the admin settings:

You can also set default tag notifications too. :+1:

3 לייקים