הוספת אפשרות חדשה לראות קבוצות: בעלים, חברים וצוות

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

Users discussed adding a new group visibility option to allow visibility for group owners, members, and staff (including moderators). Grayden_Shand noted the current options exclude moderators from viewing groups unless visibility is set to “Group owners and staff,” which then hides the group from members. Amy_Mattila echoed this need. sam proposed renaming “Group owners, members” to “Group owners, members and moderators” to include moderators, arguing it’s odd to exclude them unless necessary. This change was implemented in commit 2bf0c41 vinothkannans. tgxworld questioned whether moderators should only see groups if SiteSetting.moderators_manage_categories_and_groups is enabled, but jomaxro clarified that setting only affects management rights, not visibility. jamie.wilson acknowledged the risk of moderators accidentally locking themselves out of groups but noted admins can restore access — “great power comes with great responsibility.” The consensus supported the rename without adding a new option, and the change was implemented.

I’d like a group to be visible to Admins & Moderators and group members. Initially I had set the group’s visibility to “Group owners, members”, but this excludes moderators. The next closest option is “Group owners and staff” – this allows moderators to see the group, however, then the group is hidden to group members themselves.

So it appears there isn’t currently an option that would allow just staff (moderators and admins) and group members (and presumably group owners as well) to see a group.

I propose adding a new option to this list, or changing the Group owners, members option to Group owners, members, and staff, to include moderators as well as admins.

7 לייקים

I was curious as to if you found a way to do this? Any progress? I’m in the same situation as I would like moderators to have access to view all Groups but not be Admins. Does anyone know if this is possible?

This is certainly odd on a few fronts.

Not matter what you do “admins” are going to have access. The word staff there is a bit misleading.

I guess I support changing it to:

  • Everyone
  • Logged on users
  • Group owners, members, moderators
  • Group owners and moderators
  • Group owners

It seems super odd to lock moderators out of the group visibility except for extremely rare cases.

@codinghorror you good with this change

Group owners, members => Group owners, members and moderators ?

I am not sure we need one more option here.

(note it will take at least 1 month till we get to this change)

6 לייקים

It is changed in the below commit.

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/2bf0c4188bbc0d330f58f2eb44210e802c8fc98a

4 לייקים

Sorry I’m late to the game here but I’m not sure if this is right anymore with the introduction of SiteSetting.moderators_manage_categories_and_groups. Should we only allow moderators to see groups with a visibility of Group owners, memebers only if that site setting has been enabled?

@jamie.wilson Do you have any thoughts about this since you have the full context surrounding SiteSetting.moderators_manage_categories_and_groups.

לייק 1

The site setting doesn’t, and shouldn’t, impact group visibility. If the setting is on, moderators can only manage groups they can see. Just like it worked with categories before the setting was renamed and expanded.

2 לייקים

Ah icic. I had the impression that if the site setting is turned on, group moderators are allowed to manage any group which isn’t the case as you’ve pointed out.

2 לייקים

Right… This leads to a possible scenario where a moderator could make changes to a group such that they can no longer see/moderate that group.

But great power comes with great responsibility, right?

(If a moderator was to make such a change by accident, they’d have to get an admin to change to the group visibility settings.)

3 לייקים