Users discuss whether they can see their permissions in a Discourse forum. jimkleiber is concerned about user confusion regarding permissions in different categories. Stranik suggests a theme or plugin to display permissions clearly. pfaffman explains that missing permissions are indicated by disabled buttons, such as the “+ new topic” button, which is grayed out and shows a cursor on hover. Mittineague notes that on tablets, the hover effect is unavailable, making it less clear. codinghorror mentions that @dax has advocated for a comprehensive permissions view. dax confirms that a new tab in groups now shows category interaction permissions, but trust-level restrictions still rely on visual cues like disabled buttons.
I’m thinking to set up a forum for learning where some categories will let users only see topics, others will let them reply/see topics, and others will let them create/reply/see topics.
I’m a bit concerned that users will be confused if they don’t know which permissions they have in which categories, not knowing how they can interact with them and what new trust level or user group they would have to join to gain those new permissions.
Is there any way that I, as a user, could see which permissions I have related to creating/replying/seeing and in which categories?
If they can’t see the categories, then they don’t see them. If they can’t post, then there’s no “new topic” button and it’s not recommended when they select a topic. If they can’t reply, then there’s no reply button.
That was my understanding. Maybe something has changed?
eg. I am not a member of the “theme author” group. When I go to the category I see a “+ new topic” button that does not function. https://meta.discourse.org/c/theme
If you have developed a theme you would like to share, PM @sam and ask to be allowed to be added to the @theme_authors group so you can post your theme.
I don’t have much faith that members actually read what’s important to read, so IMHO it would be better to not show a non-functioning button. Better yet might be to have the button and show some kind of “you need to ask to join” modal.