Ok I figured out the problem after looking at those poll settings. The post was created by a user that did not meet the trust requirements to create polls. So even as an admin, I could not do it because the author of the post could not.
Ok I figured out the problem after looking at those poll settings. The post was created by a user that did not meet the trust requirements to create polls. So even as an admin, I could not do it because the author of the post could not.