Edit URL into a topic title after creation?

On my forum, there are some topics built around various links. For some users, this thing is obvious, just paste the link to the topic title box, and the result works great, e.g.:

However, the problem is when users doens’t know/care about this feature, and paste the url into the composer, not into the title.

And hence is my question: me, as a moderator/admin, how can i switch a regular topic to an url topic?


Side quest: there is a way to automatically add a tag to topic-links or at least search only on these topics?

Thanks!

(i have no idea how this feature is called though)

1 Like

At the moment I don’t think it is possible. @neil recently added the ability to remove an erroneously created “topic link”, so maybe that UI can be extended with an edit button at some point in the future.

7 Likes

Correct, there’s currently no way to go backwards from a topic to a link.

Is there a way we can make it more clear to your users that they could have pasted the link into the first field? The placeholder text says they can paste a link, so if they chose not to do that maybe they didn’t want the link.

4 Likes

I have no idea. The single user I’ve asked about this responded me that he simply didn’t noticed this feature.

Probably it is more like a habbit of 20+ years of classic forums, where users could enter only the title in the „title” box :slight_smile:

6 Likes

Hello,
My language is Vietnamese, so, after i create topic, the link is been convert so ugly, not beautifull. Can i make up theme? And how?
Thank you!

Can you screenshot what you mean?

3 Likes

Are there any news on a feature to add a URL into an existing post?

1 Like

I’m just running into an interesting challenge here - lots of people are replying to other posts with links to covid-19 resources, which we want to move into their own topics in a resources sub-category. When moving the posts and choosing the new topic, pasting the URL into the topic title does not work. It just looks like a URL in the new topic instead of getting the title from the page. It then needs to be edited to fix it, and does not have the nifty link in topic lists.

Is there a particular reason why it is not possible to add the link after the title has been written and the post saved? It comes up frequently in our community, usually when a moderator wants to add the link later to a topic posted by someone else.

I’m not sure we’ve ever been told explicitly why, but it has been confirmed a few times in the past that it isn’t possible at present:

I’m just glad we got the option to remove erroneous links, although there have definitely been occasions I would have wanted to add a link after a topic had been created.

3 Likes

Honestly based on what I’ve seen the feature isn’t used enough to justify its existence at this point, much less do more engineering work on it?

We could run stats on our hosting but I’m pretty sure I know what those stats will look like…

4 Likes

This makes sense to me. I guess it’s a power feature and we can tell people who are curious how it works and its limitations.

But It is a nice feature especially for quickly sharing links to talk about on the forum. So please don’t remove it! :wink:

1 Like

I wonder if this is a result of ignorance rather than lack of desire. I’ve been using Discourse for some time (and even developed some plugins for it) but for some reason was unaware of this feature.

I do wonder if this really should have been a category level setting, something that forces people to always include a url in every new topic for a specific category.

That said, if we added something like this, we would be stuck with teaching people about the category setting so :man_shrugging:

1 Like

I just discovered this functionality thanks to another topic asking about it. It is GREAT !
I tested a little to see how it works. It’s a bit complicated :wink: It seems you have to enter the URL first into the title. You can’t write anything else, and then want to add an URL (but you can enter the URL and then write something else, even before the URL). [EDIT: Only for a NEW post. You can’t edit an existing title]

The way you have to enter it is also a bit tricky: You have to write http:// or https://, and after that, write the complete URL without pausing for too long :wink: But you have to pause just after having written it (even adding a single space after, without having paused, will make that it doesn’t work).

The way I understand it is that http(s):// has to be detected at the very beginning of the title, and it will take what has been entered after it, as soon as there is a small pause (That’s it. This is the URL, and it can’t be changed afterwards. Not now. Not ever. It can only be removed later. If there is any space in what you entered, discourse won’t do anything and treat what you entered as a “classic” title. The link seems to be checked when validating the post: If there is no dot present, it will say it’s invalid. Copy/pasting works, with all he same parameters: You have to paste ONLY the URL; at the very beginning; no space. You can add what you want, AFTER that)

To remove it, you have to click the edit icon above, near the title. The edit function under the post don’t propose to remove the link.

So, as said, all this is a little tricky when you don’t know, but it’s still great.

3 Likes

Why wouldn’t you just paste the link in, as opposed to typing it?

2 Likes

I don’t really understand the question. Paste it from where ? If you want to copy/paste something, sure. But you also have all the times where you want to mention an URL you remember/know. Is your point to then type it somewhere else and copy/paste it ? What is the logic here ? (other than knowing that doing so solves a potential problem with discourse)

The feature was originally added because people wanted to share a link they copied from somewhere else to start a new discussion.

4 Likes

What are we? Savages???

:laughing: