As a user I find the amount of badges you have excessive. With this many the perceived value of each is probably very low. Also who of your community is familiar with all of them? Can be only a very few nerds.
I admit I am not a fan of badges / achievements in general. Although as a moderator I regularly check Autobiographer, as the profile is sometimes used for spam.
Is your team evaluating badges to analyse forum activity? That might warrant lots of them.
Now I wonder if you can have hidden badges, which are only used internally…