The discussion revolves around whether a forked version of Discourse can be submitted for managed hosting. pebble is exploring changes to SSO login, considering an iframe-based approach, but acknowledges the plugin architecture might not offer sufficient control. merefield and pfaffman strongly advise against maintaining a fork, emphasizing that plugins are more robust, require less maintenance, and are the preferred approach. pfaffman shares experience managing Discourse, noting that forks are unsustainable without dedicated developers. eviltrout confirms that Discourse.org would not host a fork, even on the Enterprise Plan, and stresses the need for plugins or theme components. pebble remains open to exploring plugins further.
I’m still looking through the source so maybe it will work. but getting more convinced the plugin architecture doesn’t give me quite enough control to achieve what I need.
I think you have to consider the architecture and not get too insistent on having an embedded iframe, for example.
Pop-up login windows and callbacks are standard practice, for example, and very straightfoward with a plugin.
Managing a fork of Discourse would be an utterly inefficient approach and an ongoing nightmare. In contrast, if built right, plugins can be very robust to change and require much less maintenance.
Those who tried to maintain a forked version of Discourse are very sorry. You’ll either need to have a full time developer or integrate changes or never upgrade. And in the end you’ll move to a plugin.
I suspect that you can do what you need in a plugin, or could make it do whet you need through a PR. You should either explain why you think you can’t solve your problem in a plugin or post in Marketplace for help.
I manage discourse as a part of my business (Redirecting…) and have a few clients who need custom configuration but cannot afford enterprise level hosting. I would love your business, but wouldn’t consider supporting a fork.
I can also confirm that at Discourse.org we would not host a fork of Discourse either, even on our Enterprise Plan. You must create plugins/theme components for your changes