Continuing the discussion from Make Discourse play nice with the Wayback Machine:
[quote=“codinghorror, post:7, topic:34579, full:true”]
Where are you getting this data from? [/quote]
Measuring from my own site on a text-only topic, no cache, I’m getting 4.3 MB. At 56k simulated speeds in Chrome dev tools, it churns for 15-20 minutes and times out, less than a quarter of it loaded. (I’m still trying to find out why my site is heavier than meta… ) I have yet to successfully load a page at this speed.
I’m not saying there are lots of dial up folks out there. But there are a few left, by choice or necessity.
Verizon inherited about 2.3 million AOL dial up customers, according to Time magazine. And 3% of Americans still use dial up at home, according to this research group.
On top of that, folks throughout the developing world have limited access speed and data caps - not to mention under-powered hardware. A simpler, lighter interface will open the door to them as well.
Obviously we aren’t catering to these folks… but since we already serve up an stripped down HTML version, making it functional will let them participate.
Here’s some other big sites that present a functional stripped down version.
Facebook now has “Facebook Lite”: http://techcrunch.com/2015/06/04/download-facebook-lite/
Gmail has basic HTML: https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=html
Twitter with javascript disabled redirects to https://mobile.twitter.com, and is functional.
Google Search with javascript disabled redirects to an older but functional version (and slims down from 362kb to 62kb).