Continuing the discussion from Digital Ocean is blocking outgoing mail! : It seems that Digital Ocean is blocking out bound SMTP traffic for at least some customers. My guess is that soon you’ll have to jump through hoops to be able to access a remote SMTP port. Simple solution: Mailgun, Sendgrid, a…

[изображение] pfaffman: I’ll include a link to this post in my next exchange with them. OK then, let me give you the full spiel, then: Port 25 outbound is an obvious candidate for filtering, because if you can hit the Internet on port 25, you can deliver e-mail to practically anyone. If tha…

I’ll submit that next time I get to a computer. I suspect it’s new accounts that are getting filtered, which is a significant proportion of my installs. A while back, mailgun started requiring credit cards; I told people to give credit card numbers. I can’t suggest a fix here (Other than use 2525). …

[изображение] pfaffman: adding a simple “can we connect to the smtp server at all” test still seems like a reasonable idea. Probably fine to quick test the 587 port during setup and warn if it is not working, but that is not what was proposed in first post.

I had some emails forwarding through my server (at DO) and they indeed got blocked. Nothing related to Discourse. But they are indeed cracking down on some servers and they are going by the policy shoot… then ask. So we had to go through all these hoops to get our email back. Just my 2c

Well, I can’t say this is new: [image] This was on 2014-12-25, and I didn’t get my Discourse for Christmas.

Not new, but I’ve not seen it until now, and the install that I just did. . . root@online:~# telnet smtp.mailgun.org 587 Trying 50.17.85.209... ^C root@online:~# ^C root@online:~# telnet smtp.mailgun.org 2525 Trying 52.24.219.230... Connected to smtp.mailgun.org. Escape character is '^]'. 220 ak47 …

[изображение] pfaffman: Not new, but I’ve not seen it until now, and the install that I just did. . . Yeah, they say it depends on your context. If you come from a 3rd world country IP, you get all sorts of problems like that. At OVH I can’t even get a server. It’s like credit, DO will analy…

[изображение] Falco: It’s like credit, DO will analyze all the info they have on you, and if you check enough boxes, you are a potential spammer / abuser and gets a different config. Could we sue then for this prejudice against us? :wink: Just kidding. But indeed I got blocked here. So that…

Lovely explication, @mpalmer . Crickets from Digital Ocean. I’ve changed my install script to use 2525 since there’s no easy way to tell whether 587 is blocked (my script blindly pipes values into ./discourse-setup so that I’m continually making sure that it’s working correctly). It appears that pe…

[изображение] pfaffman: I propose these changes to discourse-setup changing default SMTP port for those services to 2525. adding a test (e.g., nc -z -w5 smtp.mailgun.org 25) to see if the chosen SMTP port is open Why those 3 services services? They’re the ones that discourse-setup currently k…

Proposed changes to discourse-setup because Digital Ocean blocks outbound smtp

Разработка

nathank (Nathan Kershaw) 05.Май.2025 07:24:19 23

Are you willing to submit a PR for discourse-setup to make it the new default?

Тема		Ответов	Просм.
Looks like DO is disabling Smtp in their Discourse hosting plans Self-hosting hosting	25	779	20.08.2024
DigitalOcean blocking SMTP and forcing SendGrid usage Support email	12	3701	17.05.2025
Any alternative way to connect to email service then SMTP (on Digital Ocean) Support email	6	368	18.04.2025
Digital Ocean, SendGrid, Netlfity - Register Admin account email not coming through Self-hosting	30	3161	29.12.2020
Digital Ocean blocking Port 587 Support	1	605	31.03.2025

Proposed changes to discourse-setup because Digital Ocean blocks outbound smtp

Связанные темы