Use keyboard shortcuts, regardless of the keyboard layout

Good afternoon!

To use keyboard shortcuts to the user with different from the Latin keyboard layout, must switch it first. It is not too convenient.

Maybe it makes sense to add bindings to the file app/assets/javascripts/discourse/lib/keyboard-shortcuts.js.es6 for the keys that relevant to Latin keys?

Here is implementation for users with a Cyrillic keyboard:

'№':               {handler: 'goToPost', anonymous: true},
'\\':              {handler: 'toggleSearch', anonymous: true},
'+':               {handler: 'toggleHamburgerMenu', anonymous: true},
',':               {handler: 'showHelpModal', anonymous: true},
'ю':               {click: '.alert.alert-info.clickable', anonymous: true}, // show incoming/updated topics
'и':               {handler: 'toggleBookmark'},
'с':               {handler: 'createTopic'},
'ctrl+а':          {handler: 'showPageSearch', anonymous: true},
'command+а':       {handler: 'showPageSearch', anonymous: true},
'ctrl+з':          {handler: 'printTopic', anonymous: true},
'command+з':       {handler: 'printTopic', anonymous: true},
'в':               {postAction: 'deletePost'},
'у':               {postAction: 'editPost'},
'end':             {handler: 'goToLastPost', anonymous: true},
'command+down':    {handler: 'goToLastPost', anonymous: true},
'а':               {handler: 'toggleBookmarkTopic'},
'п р':             {path: '/', anonymous: true},
'п д':             {path: '/latest', anonymous: true},
'п т':             {path: '/new'},
'п г':             {path: '/unread'},
'п с':             {path: '/categories', anonymous: true},
'п е':             {path: '/top', anonymous: true},
'п и':             {path: '/bookmarks'},
'п з':             {path: '/my/activity'},
'п ь':             {path: '/my/messages'},
'home':            {handler: 'goToFirstPost', anonymous: true},
'command+up':      {handler: 'goToFirstPost', anonymous: true},
'о':               {handler: 'selectDown', anonymous: true},
'л':               {handler: 'selectUp', anonymous: true},
'д':               {click: '.topic-post.selected button.toggle-like'},
'ь ь':             {handler: 'setTrackingToMuted'}, // mark topic as muted
'ь к':             {handler: 'setTrackingToRegular'}, // mark topic as regular
'ь е':             {handler: 'setTrackingToTracking'}, // mark topic as tracking
'ь ц':             {handler: 'setTrackingToWatching'}, // mark topic as watching
'щ':         		 {click: '.topic-list tr.selected a.title', anonymous: true}, // open selected topic
'з':               {handler: 'showCurrentUser'},
'й':               {handler: 'quoteReply'},
'к':               {postAction: 'replyToPost'},
'ы':               {click: '.topic-post.selected a.post-date', anonymous: true}, // share post
'shift+о':         {handler: 'nextSection', anonymous: true},
'shift+л':         {handler: 'prevSection', anonymous: true},
'shift+з':         {handler: 'pinUnpinTopic'},
'shift+к':         {handler: 'replyToTopic'},
'shift+ы':         {click: '#topic-footer-buttons button.share', anonymous: true}, // share topic
'shift+я shift+я': {handler: 'logout'},
'е':               {postAction: 'replyAsNewTopic'},
'г':               {handler: 'goBack', anonymous: true},
'ч к':             {click: '#dismiss-new,#dismiss-new-top,#dismiss-posts,#dismiss-posts-top'}, // dismiss new/posts
'ч е':             {click: '#dismiss-topics,#dismiss-topics-top'} // dismiss topics
4 « J'aime »

My concern here is around the overlapping letters like a and e.

Perhaps a site setting to switch this for communities that use Cyrillic? Which locales do we have now that use this layout?

3 « J'aime »

a and а might look the same, but are different characters: a а

Same with e and е. I expect users of Cyrillic keyboards will get that immediately.

5 « J'aime »

Here are the Cyrillic-Latin keyboard:

I mean here that if at the moment I have Cyrillic layout, then i should switch it (Shift+Alt) to Latin for Discourse keyboard shortcuts using.

I propose to add additional bindings to resolve this issue, for example:

  • for share: 's,ы': {click: '.topic-post.selected a.post-date', anonymous: true}
  • for likes: 'l,д': {click: '.topic-post.selected button.toggle-like'}
    etc. There is no overlapping.
1 « J'aime »

Yeah, +1

it’s annoying when the shortcuts don’t work in some layout.

e.g. Ctrl+Ы works as Ctrl+S in most apps, and even on Discourse Ctrl+:ru: А works as Ctrl+F. But other shortcuts like k, j do not work here in Russian layout.

1 « J'aime »

Nous sommes ouverts à une PR qui corrige ce problème, car nous n’avons personne dans l’équipe avec un clavier disposant d’une disposition russe.

GMail fonctionne-t-il comme prévu ici ?

2 « J'aime »

Oui, et YouTube aussi.

Cela devrait être facile à tester : vous pouvez simplement ajouter une autre disposition dans votre système d’exploitation et appuyer sur les mêmes touches que d’habitude. De plus, tous les systèmes d’exploitation incluent des claviers virtuels ou à l’écran.


Concernant la solution de contournement suggérée dans le premier message, ne serait-il pas préférable d’utiliser les codes des touches plutôt que les lettres de chaque disposition non latine ? À ma connaissance, ils sont identiques partout.

3 « J'aime »