I think the success of Top relies heavily on the forum being active.
As for the algorithm, hopefully you are more math savvy than I am.
It’s been many years since I learned, and have since only rarely used, logarithms. I know what they are and I can use them, but I am stonewalled when it comes to “reading” them.
What is clear to me by looking at the file @Pad_Pors linked to is that the multiplier settings influence the “weight” of views and likes and the settings (via log, ack!) affect the “score”.
What is also obvious is that
- likes count
- op likes count
- post count
- view count
are considered in determining the topics “score”
I think what the situation is in terms of Top is that Top will be a bit less than ideal until the forum gains some traction.
AFAIK there is little that can be done to change this other than tweak the multipliers (sorry, it’s log involved there, I’m clueless in Seattle) and maybe have those (i.e. Staff) that are active make posts, view posts, and like posts at least until members get involved.
As for the time filters, errm, that will take time to level out.