Similar to some bugs before, if you look at the post count given in the linking box of a post, it gives the post #. However, this doesn’t match the numbers displayed in the navigation bar on the right. I think this topic may demonstrate the problem: Migrate a phpBB3 forum to Discourse - #580 by ge…

[изображение] TallTrees: critical/paranoid members who somehow imagine something terrible going on right, but this is not a software problem with Discourse, just reassure your users that it’s normal and carry on. There is 0.0% chance we will be changing this behavior.

[изображение] riking: aren’t willing to compromise on the position of displaying posts in order (such as how large platforms like Twitter are handling the deleted posts issue). Would you be willing to expand or link to reference on what twitter is doing? I’m not a tweeter, so have no referenc…

Here’s the pithy version :blush: check that date [изображение] wint (dril) ME: please show me the posts in the order that they were made COMPUTER: thats too hard. heres some tweets i think are good. Do you like this 12:36 AM - 4 Aug 2016 35K …

Ahh… the curated order thing. I hadn’t thought of the effect that this would have on records of deleted posts, etc.

[изображение] riking: I’m of the opinion that it’s a combination of necessary transparency and not-going-to-be-noticed. Yep - I totally agree with that. That’s why I think it would be better if the two ‘post numbers’ shown on the same screen agree (screen shot is in my post above), even if t…

[изображение] TallTrees: Given the scroller on the page knows the ‘visible’ number of each post, I’m not sure why this would be hard to re-use on the post dialog, but then I’ve not looked at the code either! I also don’t know how the code handle it, but my guess is that the total count can be…

[изображение] lucasbasquerotto: It could also be made with a background process that updates the numeration of the posts whenever a new post is created or deleted (and having a wrong numeration in the meantime). Another thing that would have to be done in the background would be to change the…

[изображение] lucasbasquerotto: On the other hand, showing each post actual number (ignoring whispers and deleted posts) could cause a huge penalty in the performance to have a near zero benefit. I think that’s unlikely. As you scroll down a page, the actual visible post number is already sh…

I can’t test with this topic because the numbers are correct, but if the current number in the timeline is correct and can be associated with the post, then that would require only a small change at the front-end. So, yeah, that could be achieved without penalties (as long as only the post number ch…

Yep - exactly that. The timeline does it right, so reusing that data \ logic would for the post # (but not in the URL) is all that’s needed.

So what you are saying is that if anyone ever links externally to post #17 and we take them to post #78 cause a bunch of posts got deleted - no problems - better design? What is the point of half changing this?

Whispered replies leak in the post number

Поддержка

riking (Kane York) 25.Январь.2021 23:34:35 30

But then you’re just going to get people asking why this is happening.

2 лайка

Тема		Ответов	Просм.
Post URLs different from Post numbers Support	7	536	14.09.2020
Toggle Whisper :eye: Theme component whispers	41	3550	25.06.2025
Unfortunately I had to pull the plug Community Building	98	11575	24.12.2022
Post number on slider disagrees with post Support	12	905	13.01.2023
Questions about moving an existing forum to Discourse Community Building	23	3070	23.11.2021

Whispered replies leak in the post number

Связанные темы