Disappeared topic: emails-suddenly-stopped-being-sent, 109077

AI-generated summary

A user dandv noticed that a topic titled “emails-suddenly-stopped-being-sent” (ID 109077) had disappeared from the forum, prompting concern over the deletion of old content. codinghorror explained that the topic was removed as part of routine culling of outdated or obsolete discussions to improve search relevance and reduce confusion. dandv expressed skepticism, questioning the necessity of deleting topics given cheap storage and the potential for broken links, while acknowledging the need for selective censorship. codinghorror emphasized that outdated topics can mislead users by appearing in search results and displacing current, relevant information, especially when referencing features that no longer exist. The discussion highlights tension between preserving historical content and maintaining a clean, up-to-date knowledge base.

Our forum suddenly stopped sending emails yesterday, so I Googled for “discourse suddenly stopped sending emails”, which led to this result. However, that topic is gone. What happened?

Not quite sure where to append ?status=deleted per this post; tacking it onto https://meta.discourse.org doesn’t show anything in particular about deleted topics.

Searching here for the title of that topic, doesn’t bring it up.

1 Like

Oh sorry I misunderstood the question! We regularly cull old / obsolete / out of date topics to make room for more up to date ones. So that topic was indeed deleted.

4 Likes

If you start a new topic we can help you troubleshoot.

3 Likes

I’m… not sure how I feel about that. I mean, I’m for selective censorship, otherwise blatant misinformation and spam/crap/junk lower the signal to noise ratio, but deleting old topics to “make room” for new ones (in the age of cheap terabyte storage, on a text forum, not Netflix) is highly questionable IMO.

Is that what happened to these two topics?

Deleting doesn’t communicate anything about the deletion reason. Adding a pointer to the current information (ideally in the OP, since this is done by admins) does, and prevents broken links.

They end up as search land mines, anyone stepping on them is exposed to old, out of date information that is no longer relevant. It causes actual harm by displacing valid search results with invalid, obsolete search results.

The goal is to reduce confusion by replacing outdated, irrelevant information (perhaps referring to features that don’t even exist any more, or exist in a completely different form) with newer, relevant information.

1 Like