First off, sorry for the really late reply. It is only up to now that I’ve had some real interest in the Top page, as we may be shifting/trying it out as our homepage soon to see if it increases activity (and your recent post reminded me of this topic).
So I like the direction where this is going. Especially for our audience, where the initial discussion post is typically a question with the original poster not certain as to what direction is best to go. “Large applications without ORM?”, where the first response may get a ton of likes because it provided a good point for the user to consider, but the actual question itself may generate zero likes as it was just a user who was uncertain about the best approach to take.
I also like this idea. I think having several contributors in the discussion is meaningful. That means you have more than just 3 people chatting back and forth, so you get a wider set of opinions/statements from a variety of backgrounds.
Currently, I don’t hold a lot of weight to the first post in a topic, that is the starter discussion, I would have thought most of the likes would occur in reply 2-19 and maybe a few less frequent posts beyond post 20 (I don’t have any metrics to support that though).