I am able to poll the set address and create group messages but removing that email from the group and attaching to a category I consistently get the email_reject_bad_destination_address error message. We’re sorry, but your email message to [“team@MMMMMM.org”] (titled testing email to category) d…

Yes, PITA :100: agree The docs are appreciated but some updating would be helpful for the next folks to come along. For example I did not realize the Forwarded emails behavior setting was required and critical. Once I realized this was the only thing that I had not tried some quick trial and error …

[image] Reply by email address broken This works as expected and the email now comes from community.forum+@domain.com with the reply-to header also set correclty. How did you set up polling for community.forum@domain.com ??

[image] Reply by email address broken Discourse ignores the Reply by email address if the email address does not contain %{reply_key} That’s expected. The reply_key is what connects the reply with the thing that you’re replying to. If there’s a bug, it’s that it allows you to enter anything wi…

Either you have your own SMTP / POP server or you can forward the emails from domain.com to gmail and have discourse poll gmail.

Thanks for the reply… I referred to that address as your example of what was working. I don’t use gmail or domain.com Yes, I have my own mail server with 4 related addresses 3 of which are forwarded to the 4th. The 4th is polled by discourse. Two of forwarded emails are used on Group A and the 3…

Hi @Lilly thanks for moving some posts around however you marked my issue solved incorrectly. Please remove or change the :white_check_mark: [image] philh: Once I realized this was the only thing that I had not tried some quick trial and error got things working. Setting to “quote” did the tric…

@Lilly closed the PM on this without waiting for a response. hmmm If I offended by sending PM I apologize. My PM response: Thanks Lilly. not about stats. It is about not misleading other users trying to sort incoming mail. Using gmail is a work around method when the SMTP server has issues with app…

Configuring Incoming Email to Create Category Topics or Group Messages

Support

RBoy (RBoy) August 30, 2025, 10:09pm 6

Yeah it’s a PITA but this is how I got it to work, don’t use a reply key and forward replies from reply@domain.com to something@gmail.com and have discourse poll gmail.com

Topic		Replies	Views
Discourse Reply via Email NEVER works Support	5	1487	January 7, 2016
Incoming email replies do not share the same topic Support email-in	6	198	December 9, 2025
Issue when allowing reply-to posts and email to create topics General	0	621	March 15, 2021
Reply-via-email to another address Support	8	1315	January 16, 2019
Discourse will not accept forwarded email but successfully sends and an error message to the original sender? Support	7	115	August 22, 2024

Configuring Incoming Email to Create Category Topics or Group Messages

Related topics