Post without signup?

Contribute Feature

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around allowing anonymous posting in Discourse without requiring users to sign up. Raphael_Haase_NL inquires about this possibility, and Noah751 responds that only registered users can post anonymously by enabling the “Allow Users to switch to anonymous mode” site setting.

hellekin suggests an alternative approach using “email-in” with staged users, but later clarifies that this method doesn’t allow switching to an anonymous account. VNVJeep and HAWK point out the confusion, and codinghorror explains how registered users can switch to anonymous mode.

Remah notes that allowing unregistered users to post anonymously is not a core feature, not available in a plugin, and not planned in core. Faizan_Zahid expresses interest in implementing features to allow unregistered users to post anonymously and create categories with only anonymous posts.

1

Is there a way to allow posting anonymously without users signing up in Discourse?

1 Mi Piace
Is there still no way for unregistered users to post?
2

Not while signed out, only users that have an account, you can enable " Allow Users to switch to anonymous mode" site setting in your forum, for users to be able to switch to a completely anonymous account.

3

If you use email-in, you can setup an email address for a category that will enable “anonymous users” to participate. This requires “staged users”, then in a category :

2017-10-04-180514_726x617
2017-10-04-180514_726x617726Ă—617 43.1 KB

You need to setup the engage@example.org email address to forward to your installation’s discourse email (the one you POP.)

5 Mi Piace
4

That looks like a good idea! I followed your link to staged users and do not understand the connection. Could it be that you linked the wrong URL?

1 Mi Piace
5

Yes, you’re right. I corrected the link.

1 Mi Piace
6

I have enabled this setting, however, I’m not seeing how you can switch to an anonymous account? How do you do this?

7

Click or tap your user avatar at the upper right, then the spy / anonymous glyph.

1 Mi Piace
8

I think they’re talking about staged users here though…

9

Staged users haven’t logged in so that doesn’t make sense to me? You must log in to be able to switch to anonymous.

10

Agreed. I think there is some confusion stemming from this:

11

Yes! Thanks for that. Didn’t notice that inconspicuous little icon before. :wink:

12

Do you understand that a staged user won’t be able to do that though? They are only interacting with the site via email.

1 Mi Piace
13

Yeah… Not a problem. The only users I’m concerned about are registered users on my site.

2 Mi Piace
15

Per quanto ne so, questa non è una funzionalità di base, non è disponibile in un plugin e non è prevista nel core:

Per tua informazione, sono state richieste più volte tre funzionalità di pubblicazione anonima. Solo una è stata implementata:
:heavy_check_mark: consentire a un utente registrato di pubblicare in modo anonimo (mentre è connesso)
:x: consentire a un utente non registrato di pubblicare in modo anonimo
:x: consentire una categoria con solo post anonimi, ovvero anche gli utenti registrati possono pubblicare solo in modo anonimo

3 Mi Piace
17

Sarebbe fantastico vedere implementate anche queste due funzionalitĂ :

  • consentire a un utente non registrato di pubblicare in forma anonima
  • consentire una categoria che contenga solo post anonimi, ovvero anche gli utenti registrati possano pubblicare solo in forma anonima
2 Mi Piace