Yeah, if you have a special title it’d be nice to click through to see some information about it.
OTOH, it’s pretty unclear that clicking on “co-founder” should bring you to the list of Discourse team members.
I’m looking at the way groups were used on freeallegiance.org - the biggest forum I’ve been part of - and it was mainly an ACL method. We’d have:
- one group per clan (9x)
- one group per clan officiers (9x)
- one group per extra officiers (1x)
- one group per training group (3x)
- one group per training group trainers (3x)
- one group per community area (6x)
- one group per community area leaders (1x)
- one group per development team (3x)
- one group per development team friends (3x)
- one group per super user access (a bunch of them)
- weird combinations thereof for corner cases
For context, at one point I was a clan member, a clan officier, a trainer, a member of three community areas, a member of two developer friends’ teams and a wiki cop. (Yes, it was the largest forum I’ve been in, but I never said it was particularly large, although it probably was particularly over-engineered.)
Still, I’d have had a pretty hard time picking one hat from all of these, and certainly it wouldn’t fit the entirety of my forum activity. Maybe, down the line, this group digest feature should be tied somehow to the category your posts are made in? …or perhaps the whole setup they had was not particularly compatible with the way Discourse wants to take online communities.
It probably might even make sense to choose the hat, or title, you’re going to wear on a per-post basis, and then filter based on that. Sort of like this:
When you author a post, you get to choose what title to wear, if any:
Replying to post 3 by codinghorror as [a regular forum user [ v ]:
[a regular forum user ]
[a wiki administrator ]
[a Steel Fury member ]
[a Steel Fury asst. leader]
[an events zone organizer ]
[a codinghorror reverse-f…]
If you pick an hat, then the left gutter proudly displays it:
. bp_ Lorem ipsum quod erat Chromebook non
@codinghorror once said adaptus ad freehandi circulo mockum up.
I was pretty awesome Damnatio!
…and as a result the post is featured on
http://meta.discourse.org/groups/codinghorror-reverse-fan-club
which you could access by clicking on the left gutter grey text.
So, for example, you @codinghorror could decide to be a team member for most things, but when it’s time for the big announcement blog post time or the executive decision, you would sport the super-fancy “co-founder” title to show that you are meaning business and your word is final.
I know you don’t roll like that, I know you probably won’t like this approach, so I don’t expect it to become part of Discourse. It would probably also be overkill for most communities; the very idea of having a title might tempt people into creating 1-man groups for personalized titles, thus missing the point of groups completely.
I think it still makes a modicum of sense and consistency. Also, it’s 2am. Yawn.