This is my 3rd time installing Discourse and I’m experiencing this issue for the first time. Whenever you make an account, the activation email goes to spam’s folder. Already tested with Gmail and Hotmail. Mail-tester shows 10/10. Our email domain is noreply@domain.com
AI-generated summary
User calebs reports that activation emails for their Discourse forum are consistently landing in spam folders, despite a perfect 10/10 score on Mail-tester and testing across Gmail and Hotmail. tobiaseigen initially suspects the domain may be blacklisted, but calebs clarifies the Mail-tester score is optimal. pfaffman suggests checking mail service logs or personal filters and recommends contacting the email provider; calebs confirms they’ve opened a ticket with Mailgun, which found no issues on their end. justin points to potential misconfigurations in SPF/DKIM records as a common cause for emails being flagged as spam—even if delivery succeeds. codinghorror highlights that Outlook/Hotmail is particularly aggressive in silently filtering or discarding unwanted mail. The issue appears isolated to this specific installation despite following identical setup steps previously successful for calebs and a friend. The community suspects domain reputation, DNS record accuracy, or recipient inbox filtering policies as likely culprits, though no definitive cause has been confirmed yet.
this likely has to do with your domain name being on a blacklist. Take a look at https://www.mail-tester.com/ and see how the email address you send from rates.
That’s strange indeed.
I would open a ticket with your mail service.
Have you tried multiple accounts? It could be that you did something in your own filters to mark the domain as spam.
Often this is due to incorrect SPF/DKIM records on the domain. Mail still goes through, but if they’re not 100% correct, major email providers will cause it to go to spam.
I’m following the exact same steps every time. Even helped a friend with their forum. Never had a problem.
Already opened a ticket with Mailgun. They said everything looked fine on their side.
Which mail inbox service? For example Outlook / Hotmail is notorious for silently discarding email it does not like.
