Builds taking very long time

Hi,

I’ve got a fresh install of ubuntu 20, docker and Discourse. I’ve not added any plugins and only have two users in my database, however builds are taking upwards of 40 minutes to complete! There’s no specific part of the build process that is slow, the entire thing takes an absolute age to complete. It’s a pretty good spec server, and I have another happily serving 20 of my clients websites, so it isnt a performance issue.

Hangs here for at least 4 minutes:

warning Resolution field "lodash@4.17.21" is incompatible with requested version "lodash@4.17.15"

Hangs again here immediately after for another 4-5 minutes:

warning " > @mixer/parallel-prettier@2.0.1" has unmet peer dependency "prettier@^2.0.0".

I’ve tried building with --skip-prereqs to no avail, it is still taking 40+ minutes each rebuild.

Is there anything in particular that you think may be causing the problem?

Thanks for your help.

Alex

5 Likes

I’ve noticed that rebuilds have been taking a long time too. How much ram do you have?

4 Likes

I rebuild my DO droplet (1 GB Memory / 25 GB Disk / LON1 - Ubuntu 20.04 (LTS) x64)

it took 20:25,44

CPU spiked as expected

memory was random

Bandwidth was surprising

1 Like

We have a regression on build times caused by the new ability to run theme tests via the UI. This is something we are tracking closely and trying to fix.

8 Likes

4GB of RAM :+1: Thanks for the update @Falco

2 Likes

Thanks for confirming @Falco, 1GB RAM here (tight but never needed more for a lightweight site). It’s taking over 30 minutes to build (normally it’s about 10).

Rafael is this regression on 2.9.0 beta or 2.8.0 stable?

Going back to the first post, anyone know where that warning is coming from?

I don’t know if it’s really something to consider, but personally, in many things I have noticed that performance drops when using Ubuntu 20.04 (Discourse, WebServers, Game Servers) even trying different ways to try to optimize :thinking:

At the moment I am running Discourse in a Droplet for tests with the same characteristics, it takes about 8-12 minutes to rebuild (Ubuntu 18)

1 Like

the build time also depends on how many plugins & theme components you have installed.

That also takes time to rebuild.

As i have all the official plugins loaded, my build takes a bit longer

1 Like

I know, but in this case I was talking about an “equality” of specifications, that is, without plugins too

1 Like

I don’t think the build is “hanging” at those warnings. It’s just silently building and the warnings are spit out as part of the process.

I.e. the warnings or their underlying issue are not contributing to the long build time.

3 Likes

Where can we track this @Falco? Thank you for letting us know about this, I just stumbled into it and it is killing us hard here.

2 Likes

This is a gigantic change we are working on for years, and is getting to the final stages. During it we have a period where “things will get worse before they get better”, and this is one of the “worse” side effects of it.

As soon as we complete New installs will default to Ember CLI builds in Production for all existing sites, and rip-off the old asset pipeline, we can then aggressively start modernizing it and hopefully collect some upstream gains.

There is also the potential for us to allow people on slow CPUs to opt-out of source maps and other “nice to have” features to speed up their rebuilds.

11 Likes

Appreciate the update @Falco :heart: On a quad CPU with 8GB RAM on Linode and normally this is a fantastic setup, but it is a nightmare now. We have a number of changes we were planning to make, but will need to wait now until the deployment get’s back to normal’ish speeds.

@Falco I’m also noticing for the last few releases that the server performance is degrading, it takes longer to load the sites and consuming more memory. There have bee no changes to my setup in the past 2 years (plugins, hardware etc) and the number of active users on the site are also the same. Is there a way to objectively monitor site performance from within Discourse that we can then report back here. Right now the only way I know is when I open the site it takes from >8 seconds to load the first time (with earlier builds it would always be under 2-3 seconds).

What kind of rebuild times are you guys seeing? I just needed to rebuild due to an SMTP change, and it clocked in at just shy of 12 minutes for a TINY site (30 users, 400 posts).

2 Likes

This topic is about “build times” not about loading page times. If you are a talking about page response times degradation, please open a new topic about it with some data.

2 Likes

Last build this morning took about 20 minutes

I will thanks, after today’s update it’s now back to the normal 2-3 seconds to load the pages (nice surprise).

Ouch. That’s not normal.

1 Like