Internal links not oneboxing in private messages


I first noticed this from the private messages I received from the “Save Searches” plugin yesterday:

I thought this was simply flaky but the same happened with today’s message.

Internal links seem to onebox fine when linking in a topic/post:

Yet it failed to onebox when I just tried to link it in a private message:

The external link on the bottom worked, in contrast.

(Régis Hanol) #4

Nice catch :wink:

(Mittineague) #5

IIRC this may have to do with a fix to a leaking problem. i.e. the public topic displayed a link to the message. Clicking the link gave the “oops or private” page, but the title of the message topic and the fact one existed was exposed. eg.

:link: Is this guy a first class numpty or what?


Follow up question: has there been a deliberate change in how a onebox to a internal link that does not belong to the current topic renders?


Linking a post in the current topic renders as “quote”: :white_check_mark:

Linking a post that does not belong to the current post used to render as the following:

But currently, also as a quote: (a possible :x:?)

(Régis Hanol) #7

Yeah, since we removed the source_topic_id parameter, there’s no way for the server to know if we’re in the same topic or not anymore…

(Sam Saffron) #8

Oh we should change this so we always use the off topic style if we must, but we can also pass in topic id with category id

(Theo) #9

Are you saying this will be corrected or there’ll be a new way to link? Linking between topics is something we find very useful.

In fact the only thing I wish it did do that it doesn’t is to display the images in the linked post too.

(Jeff Atwood) #10

This is something @zogstrip is actively working on; he’ll update in a bit.

(Régis Hanol) #11

There’s now a title when linking to a different topic


Quick demo/test:

A post in the current topic:

A post from another topic:

tada Thanks @zogstrip for following through with the issue!

What I see in composer preview:

What I see in the post:

Why do I feel like we have gone down some kind of rabbit hole…

(Régis Hanol) #13

I forgot to report back here but I fixed it yesterday

(Jeff Atwood) closed #14