Mobile composer: permanent full-screen

Summary

Mini experiment to keep mobile composer full-height, even when closing the keyboard.

Reason

  1. Avoid jumpy movements when interacting within composer, whenever the keyboard closes or opens

  2. Make re-reading your own post before submitting easier by using the fully available sceen

Screenshots

Notes

To see the forum while composing, you can still use the dedicated minimise button in the top right corner.

There may be potential differences in experiences between Hub/webapp, or the various browsers. Please report those to see if this is a viable change everywhere or not.

10 Likes

I am a huge supporter of this change, it greatly improves my mobile experience

I can always minimize if I need to read something quickly

Quoting experience is great and seems to work fine on hub :+1:

3 Likes

Hello :waving_hand: Yeah I like it too. Thanks :heart:

It would be nice if when I open the composer it would autofocus and open the keyboard on iOS as well.

The preview side is misaligned for me on iOS.

Maybe it’s just me, but I prefer having the composer at half-height when the keyboard is closed, as I need to quote different things from a post above, but this makes it harder - I have to collapse the whole composer instead.

1 Like

It works fine, can’t reproduce any bug. Also, seems very good for ios as the jump was laggy there I guess.

On a smartphone, things look good to me. However, on tablets, I am less sure.
First, when I start a reply, the composer area is quite small (screenshot from a 12.9“ iPad below), definitely smaller than it needs to be.
But when I enter the text box and start typing, the composer goes fullscreen as for my iPhone, which is not really needed IMO (and there’s also no obvious means to resize it to half size - which is probably intended).

1 Like

I’m with you, Nate, but I like to use desktop for this kind of interaction.

I think that full screen is mandatory for a clean experience on mobile; one can tap to read previous posts.

2 Likes

Yes, the tablet experience is lacking atm and has a whole bunch of other things “going on” that I need to look at to optimise things. It def needs a different approach.

1 Like

Would it be possible to have the option for both? I like the full screen for reading back, but I also like the half screen for inserting quotes and comparing my answer to the post I’m replying to. At the moment, when I minimise it places the cursor to the end of the composer text, and pops the quote there (when I wanted to put it mid post).

Could I have a button that toggles half screen/full screen (& minimise)?

1 Like

No sorry, really not planning that. It’s already crowded enough as-is.

If we just manage to address this:

That should suffice to alleviate the desire of the half-composer, no?

1 Like

Fixing that would be great. :raising_hands: :slight_smile:

But there’s also:

I like the half-composer for this too. I like the option of having both my bit and the thing I’m replying to next to each other without having to flick between screens. I think it helps me double-check what I’m saying is relevant and I’m replying to what was said and not just what I think someone said [1]


  1. results vary :slight_smile: ↩︎

3 Likes

I swore i shared this on here already.

This is the same as my forum

Without composer clicked

After clicking compose button