Modify new topic editor grey guide text/copy (per category)

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

In a discussion about customizing the grey placeholder text in Discourse’s new topic editor per category, Joshua_Kogan asks if it’s possible to tailor the guide text (e.g., “Type here. Use…”) by category. Thomas_G explains that while the admin panel allows global customization, it can’t be set per category. However, he suggests using category-specific custom templates — which replace the grey text entirely — as a workaround. Joshua_Kogan acknowledges this but notes users must then delete or overwrite the template text, which may cause confusion. Thomas_G counters that templates are more visible and helpful than the faint grey placeholder, which disappears as soon as typing begins — a common usability issue. codinghorror adds a broader observation: it’s inherently challenging to get users to follow guidance they’re indifferent to or actively ignore. The thread highlights a tension between UX design and user behavior, with templates emerging as a practical — if imperfect — solution for guiding users toward category-appropriate content.

Hi can the text below be changed per topic category?

You can customize it via the admin section of the forum, but it will appear the same for all the categories, not only let’s say for #uncategorized

I was afraid that was the answer, and was hoping a category-specific method was available.

However, there is something you might find useful. If you create a custom template for a specific category, the “Type here. Use…” will not appear and instead, what you have set as a template will appear. Although the template is something that users can delete, I always find it very useful and members very helpful, as it helps them get to know the purpose of the category.

I know about that, but then the user needs to type over, or erase that text/copy, which creates a different type of confusion.

All the users though get to read the template, whereas the grey guide text can barely been seen, not because there is an issue with it, just because some users type fast and once they type a letter, the guide disappears. Just my 2 cents. :slight_smile:

Well yes fundamentally it is difficult to get people to do things they either don’t want to do, or don’t care about :wink: