A discussion about introducing per-category and per-tag ranking factors, such as 0.9 or 1.2, to adjust the visibility of topics in certain categories or with specific tags. meglio proposed this idea to prevent non-professional topics in the “offtopic” category from dominating the /top page and giving a bad impression of the forum’s professionalism.
erlend_sh initially expressed concerns that this would make the ranking system more complex and “Reddit-esque,” but later agreed that it makes sense for the /top page. codinghorror suggested that implementing a simple per-category multiplier would be easy but might not be widely used. However, sam and codinghorror pointed out that this feature could be useful for search results, allowing certain categories to be prioritized, such as “howto.” meglio further suggested that these weight numbers could also be used for generating sitemaps.
I would like to propose to introduce per-category factors that would affect all components of a topic’s ranging system, depending on what category it is found in. The same can be applied to tags, btw.
Even though our forum is specialized in goat farming, cheese making and also aimed at milk addicts, there are topics in the “offtopic” category that sometimes get too much attention and thus get quickly to the top in the /top page. Still, I’m unhappy about making such non-professional topics to be shown above all other topics. This makes an impression that our forum is not so professional.
That’s why I’d assign a factor of 0.9 or 0.8 to the “offtopic” category.
Of course, the factor should be always 1 by default unless you explicitly enter a value other than 1.
Interesting. It conflicts with the very simple and relatable logic of “newest first” though, becoming more Reddit-esque instead. Most forums probably won’t need this.
How about you restrict your Off-topic forum to TL1 users and above? Then it won’t show up in Latest or Top for anon visitors.
For top I see this as less useful, but for search results yeah, you may want to push howto to the top always, this is something I have wanted for a while.